NBA most wasted potentials

14 NBA Players Whose Potential Got Wasted – Names That Could’ve Been

In the grand, unpredictable NBA league, some scripts end too soon, their plots twisted by the kind of drama you wish was just fiction.  Today, I want to address the ballers whose careers took a nosedive thanks to an assortment of injuries and off-court antics.

It’s a mix of “what could have been” and “oh, what a pity.” If you are a fan of the league and basketball, you will surely appreciate this list. The players I’m about to list got in all sorts of trouble. There were drugs, alcohol, but sometimes it was just injuries and plain bad luck. We have a lot to cover, so let’s begin without further ado.

1. Jay Williams

Before life decided to throw a curveball his way with that infamous motorcycle crash in 2003, Jay was basically the poster child for basketball prodigies. Winning the Naismith in 2002 like it was no big deal, right after dancing his way to an NCAA title in 2001.

And his stats? Just casually dropping 19.3 points per game, dishing out 6 assists, and grabbing 3.7 rebounds – from the point guard position, no less. The Bulls, bless their hearts, saw his brilliance and snagged him second overall in 2002, just after Yao Ming.

His rookie year was not the stuff of legends, but the sparks were there. You could almost see the Bulls thinking, “This is our guy.” It almost happened, but sadly, faith had other plans.

2. Maurice Stokes

Maurice Stokes NBA stats

Maurice Stokes was lighting up scoreboards back in the day. This guy was scoring like crazy and grabbing every rebound in sight – putting up over 16 points and 17 rebounds a game- On top of it, he was dishing out over 5 assists a contest, too.

It seemed nothing could stop this force of nature on the court. But then it all came crashing down. During a game, Maurice took a bad fall and banged his head. The injury left him paralyzed and unable to play ball anymore.

Can you imagine going from an NBA star to not being able to move at all? It gets even worse – he ended up passing away in 1970, far too young. Maurice’s career was so prosperous until that one unlucky moment changed everything.

It just goes to show you that no matter how good you are, fate can step in at any second and take it all away. A real bummer for what should have been a long, successful time in the NBA.

3. Roy Tarpley

Roy Tarpley’s story is one crazy twist after another. Just when it seemed like he was really taking off in the NBA, his problems with drinking and drugs dragged him right back down.

Because of all his issues, the league even banned him from playing anymore. He was the guy with tons of talent, but he just couldn’t get out of his own way. No matter how well he played, he always found a way to mess it up.

Whether it was missing practices or games because he was hungover or just not being able to stay clean, he never could get fully focused on basketball.

4. Grant Hill

Grant Hill injury reports

Man, Grant Hill looked like a superstar, but his ankles had other ideas. He was balling out for the Magic but only got to play 47 games over his first four seasons.  It’s like someone filled his shoes with concrete, he simply couldn’t catch a break.

Hill’s story is definitely one of the NBA’s biggest “what coulda beens,” as he was talented as anyone in the league. Grant was on his way to the top when his ankles started giving up on him. Only getting in half a season’s worth of games during those first four years in Orlando…that’s rough. It’s crazy to think what might have been if he could’ve stayed healthy.

5. Penny Hardaway

Penny Hardaway hall of fame

Your career can change in a second. We’ve all heard the stories of athletes who seemed unstoppable one minute and sidelined the next.  Penny Hardaway was living his dream in the NBA, but then – his left knee went out.

Just like that, his fairy tale turned into a nightmare. After tearing his ACL, things were never the same for Penny. It just goes to show, in basketball or anywhere else, you’re only one wrong move from everything changing.

Your body takes so many hits out there, one slip or tweak and it’s curtains. Penny went from MVP talks to missing games, trying to get his knee right. Another “what if” about Hardaway’s career is his connection with Big Diesel, Shaquille O’Neal. Everyone was predicting that this duo would be unstoppable, but the injury-riddled career of Penny Hardaway robbed us of that dream.

6. Len Bias

Can you imagine getting picked second in the NBA Draft and then never playing a single game? That’s what happened to Len Bias back in 1986. Man, what a bummer that must have been. He was on top of the world, all set to play for the Boston Celtics.

That’s a dream come true for any basketball player. But then overnight, it all changed. Drug addiction is something that can sneak up when least expected, and that’s what happened to Len Bias. Now, instead of having an amazing career in the NBA, we’re left wondering what could have been.

Cocaine addiction snatched away what could have been one of the most illustrious careers in basketball history, leaving us with a slew of what-ifs and a story that feels more myth than reality.

7. Tracy McGrady

Tracy McGrady draft profile

TMac’s career had some ups and downs that were tough to watch. It seemed like every time he started to take off, his body would give up on him. Bad back, busted shoulder, sore knees – it’s like his whole body was against him.

You’d think after all that, his career would be over. But even with all the injuries and issues, TMac just kept ballin’. Every time he came back, he’d do something so amazing it’d take your breath away.

One minute, he’s hurt, the next he’s flying through the air, throwing it down over three guys. It’s too bad his body broke down so much cause when he was on the court, ain’t nobody who could mess with TMac. His highlights are some of the best ever. Too bad his lows came from getting hurt so much.

8. Yao Ming

Yao Ming height

Yao Ming was HUGE, bigger than almost everyone else on the court. He had a chance to be one of the best big men in basketball, but his feet and knees just didn’t hold up, which is rotten luck. It’s gotta be a bummer to go from dominating with your size to not being able to play cause your body’s busted. Such a waste.

Even the biggest guy around is still just as fragile underneath. It’s too bad for Yao that he found that out the hard way. Just goes to prove that luck plays a big part, so you never know when it’ll be your turn to go down.

9. Brandon Roy

Brandon Roy injury details

Brandon Roy was lighting it up for the Portland Trail Blazers, averaging over 20 points a game and looking like a true superstar.  Here was a guy in his prime, taking the league by storm.

And then, bam, his body turns against him with those bum knees. It’s kinda sad when you imagine what Roy could have done if he just got to keep hooping without the injuries.

10. Amar’e Stoudemire

Amar'e Stoudemire wingspan

Amar’e Stoudemire was an absolute beast out there on the court. Nobody could stop that guy when he was coming at the hoop. He’d explode past defenders and just slam it down. You had to see it to believe it. Then 2005 happened.

He went and got that microfracture surgery on his knee. And just like that – poof! – his explosiveness was gone. Those highlight reel dunks started turning into air balls more than slam dunks. It was wild to see such a dominant player lose that part of his game so quickly.

But you gotta give Amar’e some credit, too. Instead of calling it quits, he worked hard to adjust his game. He became more of an outside shooter and a mid-range scorer. It wasn’t the same, but he kept balling.

His career after that surgery is a perfect example of how you gotta change up your style when injuries strike. Still, I can’t help but wonder – what if he never got hurt, and was his career wasted post-injury?

11. Keon Clark

Keon Clark’s story is one big bender – it really shows how addiction can mess up even the best of careers. And get this – Clark actually said he never played a game sober! Can you believe that?

His drinking not only tanked his game but landed him in all kinds of legal trouble. In the end, his issues with the bottle totally overshadowed anything he did on the court. Clark’s career is a real buzzkill, and it serves as a reminder of all the potential he wasted cause he couldn’t kick his habit. Sometimes, the toughest battles happen off the court, where nobody sees.

12. Mitchell Wiggins and Lewis Lloyd

NBA players who admitted to using cocaine

Mitchell and Lewis made some really bad choices. These two got themselves into a real mess. They got suspended from playing ball for two and a half years, which is essentially career suicide, especially nowadays.

Why, you ask? Well, cause they got caught using cocaine. Ain’t no way to get ahead in life, I tell you. They had to sit on the sidelines and watch everyone else have all the fun. All because they didn’t stop to think about how their actions would affect more than just themselves.

They blew it, big time, and it ain’t just them that who paid the price. Their teams got hurt, too, without these guys out on the court.

13. John Lucas

John Lucas had a real talent for playing ball, but then the party scene and everything bad off the court got to him. Drinking and drugs sunk their claws in deep. Soon, John’s game went down the tubes, and it was looking like curtains for his career.

But you know what? Dude didn’t stay down. Somehow, he found a way to climb out of the hole he dug. John got himself cleaned up, and now he’s helping other players with similar issues do the same. Pretty wild how he took all the mess of his past and turned it into something good.

Goes to show it’s never too late to change your game. John is living proof that one slip up doesn’t have to ruin your whole life. Nowadays, John is coaching and is a completely different person.

14. Ralph Sampson

Ralph Sampson twin towers

Talk about expectations being through the roof! Ralph Sampson was set to dominate the NBA at 7 foot 4. But his knees and back said, “Think again.” His body wasn’t having it, which derailed his ticket to superstardom.

Ralph’s story is one for the books – and not in a good way. He went from a can’t-miss prospect to a what-could-have-been real quick. Injuries took his talent and put it on the bench. The potential was there, but his body simply couldn’t handle it.

Final Words

And there you have it, a roll call of NBA talents whose stories are riddled with a sense of loss, a reminder of the razor-thin line between glory and what could have been.

Their careers, though spoiled by injuries and setbacks, remind us of the fragility of athletic greatness and the unyielding spirit of those who dare to chase it, even when their bodies and willpower refuse to cooperate. For more interesting NBA stories, check our website.

Recent Posts