Unfair in the Fairest Way Possible: A Modest Proposal for the NFL Draft

Share |

The Jets and Titans played two very different football games in Week 3. In New York, a roster of 52 largely competent football players found themselves hostage to the whims of Ryan Fitzpatrick’s throwing arm. They played good football and lost because their quarterback threw three interceptions. In Tennessee, a roster of 52 largely incompetent football players found themselves leading a defending AFC finalist for most of the day on the arm, legs, thorax, and pretty much everything else of Marcus Mariota. The difference between having a star like Marcus Mariota and a substitute teacher like Ryan Fitzpatrick at quarterback is hugely significant. But the difference between the Jets and Titans during the 2014 game that determined their draft position? Only five points.

There’s something arbitrarily cruel about the NFL Draft. It usually comes down to basic math. There are 32 teams in the NFL. Those teams only play 16 games. Barring ties, there are therefore only 17 possible records those 32 teams can have. That leads to quite a few ties. Sometimes, those ties are irrelevant, like when they determine the winner of the NFC South. Occasionally, they swing the history of the league forever.

The 2011 Colts and the 2011 Rams both finished 2-14. In many ways the Rams were actually the worse of the two teams. Their point differential of -214 remains the worst an NFL team has produced since and falls almost four full touchdowns below the -187 Colts. One of their two wins came against a 4-12 Browns team quarterbacked by Colt McCoy and two of their 14 losses came in a pair of 17-point blowouts to the Tarvaris Jackson-led Seahawks. Brandon Lloyd led the team with 51 receptions.

The Colts picked first because they played an easier schedule. Scratch that—the Colts picked first because they had an easier strength of schedule, a statistic that ignores fairly relevant context such as the Rams playing their final two games against the combined 25-7 Steelers and 49ers but facing their backup quarterbacks. Coincidentally enough, that metric had the Rams playing the hardest schedule in the league in 2011. The Colts were fourth by the same metric and led the AFC. The difference came largely within their divisions. The AFC South went 24-24, excluding the Colts. The NFC West went 28-20, featuring the No. 2 seeded San Francisco 49ers, and didn’t have a team besides St. Louis finish worse than 7-9. Geographic proximity to bad teams gave the Colts Andrew Luck.

On its face this seems extraordinarily stupid. But it happens all of the time. Four of the last five No. 1 picks (Tennessee in 2016, Tampa Bay in 2015, Kansas City in 2013, and Indianapolis in 2012) were determined by tiebreakers. The 2004 draft had a four-way tie for the No. 1 pick with the Giants, Chargers, Raiders, and Cardinals all finishing 4-12 and a seemingly impossible six-way tie after that with the Falcons, Texans, Jaguars, Redskins, Lions, and Browns all ending up with 5-11 records. One game separated the first and tenth picks.

When franchise quarterbacks are on the line, the difference between even first and second is enormous. Imagine a world in which the Rams magically had an easier strength of schedule than the Colts in 2011. Either the Rams stay put and grab the best quarterback prospect in decades, or they stick with Sam Bradford and the Redskins trade up. In both cases, a new contender is created out of thin air and the Colts are a drastically different team all because of one fairly subjective number. There has to be a better way to do this.

***

The great irony of the NBA Draft lottery is that, if you assume that there is an exact correlation between record and merit, basketball rarely needs it. An 82-game season is such a large sample size that the odds of the two worst teams sharing a record is relatively slim. The last time it happened was the 2002-03 season. Since then there have been three cases of the worst team finishing at least five games lower than anyone else.

But that’s precisely why the draft lottery works. There isn’t an exact correlation between a team’s record and how good or bad they are. Over a full-season, circumstance is going to influence record almost as much as talent. The lottery combats that by fighting randomness with randomness. It acknowledges that record matters but that it is an imperfect measure of performance, and, therefore, record-based outcomes should reflect that same imperfection. A 13-win team probably does deserve a better chance in the draft than a 25-win team, but the lottery allows for the realistic possibility that there isn’t all that much separating bad teams at that level.

There probably wasn’t much separating the 5-11 2003 Houston Texans and the 4-12 2003 New York Giants, and a draft order that says otherwise is irreparably flawed. A 16-game sample is far more random than the NBA’s 82. Record is a far worse measure of performance in football than in basketball. So why not let the draft order reflect just how small the difference between bad teams at that level really is?

My proposal is relatively simple. The NFL should institute a lottery that gives each team at a certain record the same odds of winning, with those odds weighted towards what the record was. If the worst team finished 1-15 and the next finished 4-12, the odds favor that 1-15 team heavily. If five teams are tied at 3-13, tiebreakers go out the window and all five of those teams get the same lottery odds. Lower the odds in that fashion until you’ve run out of non-playoff teams, let the lottery determine the top five picks before moving back to tiebreakers, and bam, we have ourselves a lottery.

The system isn’t inherently fair in the sense that it automatically rewards the most deserving team with the top pick—quite the opposite, in fact. It is fair because it acknowledges we have no idea who the most deserving team is, so it gives every candidate a chance at the top pick.

More than that, it gives every team and fan base hope for the first pick. This system might not be perfect, but it eliminates those 5-11 or 6-10 seasons that are horrible enough to dread but keeps your team in that quarterback-free limbo of the mid-first round. This system, like the NBA Draft lottery, is unfair in the fairest way possible.

Share |

Comments

You completed a few fine points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will go along with with your blog.rmofspringfield.ca

I think that thanks for the valuabe information and insights you have so provided here. Thanks for sharing us. baby float

Thanks for this great post, i find it very interesting and very well thought out and put together. I look forward to reading your work in the future. games download for phone

I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day! go to my blog

Thanks for the post and great tips..even I also think that hard work is the most important aspect of getting success.. sport waist trainer

It’s amazing in support of me to truly have a blog site, which will be valuable meant for my knowledge. Thanks admin.www.localdallaslocksmiths.com

Thanks for posting this info. I just want to let you know that I just check out your site and I find it very interesting and informative. I can't wait to read lots of your posts.roundup lawsuit 2016

Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here. surviving the final bubble review on continuumbooks.com

I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day! EDDM Printing

I’m able to bookmark your site and show the kids check out up here generally. http://www.dreamscapeartstudio.com

Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Great blog

I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share.https://www.levitradosageus24.com/

You have raised an important issue..Thanks for sharing..I would like to read more current affairs from this blog..keep posting..http://pokemongohackcheats.de

Extremely useful info specially the last part I care for such information a lot. Good articles

I really like your writing style, great information, thankyou for posting. Free Lawyer Consultation

Thanks for providing recent updates regarding the concern, I look forward to read more.
slot casino

All the contents you mentioned in post is too good and can be very useful. http://psprint.getyourcouponcodes.com/

i read a lot of stuff and i found that the way of writing to clearifing that exactly want to say was very good so i am impressed and ilike to come again in future..
seo services

Great post, you have pointed out some fantastic points , I likewise think this s a very wonderful website.
generic ieee 1284.4 printing support driver

I can’t imagine focusing long enough to research; much less write this kind of article. You’ve outdone yourself with this material. This is great content.infrared heaters

i want this article to finish my assignment within the faculty, and it has same topic together with your article. Thanks, nice share.
DietasEmagrecimento.com

Hello I am so delighted I located your blog, I really located you by mistake, while I was watching on google for something else, payday loans

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
0800

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work. Nice read

Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information.
best reviews

Thanks for the blog post buddy! Keep them coming... Thanks, that was a really cool read!
great article

Hello I am so delighted I located your blog, I really located you by mistake, while I was watching on google for something else, stamped concrete massachusetts

Nice to be visiting your blog once more, it has been months for me. Semiconductor News

i want this article to finish my assignment within the faculty, and it has same topic together with your article. Thanks, nice share.
girlsdoporn

Also, through these occasionally mass bans, amusement designers are permitting different gamers to know when they are managing bots and such. movie hd for pc

While there is very little you, an individual gamer, can do other than reporting a character or symbol you think to be a Bot, diversion designers and Wardens, which will be talked about later, are creating strategies to end the session of "feline and mouse" amongst themselves and these force leveling organizations. shareit for pc

The contrast amongst bots and different types of force leveling is that your character is not as a matter of course being played; it could be a totally distinctive character that takes every necessary step for you and afterward you gather what the Bot has earned. itube for pc

That gives off an impression of being fabulous anyway i am still not very beyond any doubt that I like it. At any rate will look much more into it and choose by and by! dispensary

I can see that you are a specialist at your field! I am dispatching a site soon, and your data will be exceptionally helpful for me.. A debt of gratitude is in order for all your help and wishing all of you the achievement in your business. dispensaries near