"So a German Sports Team Walks Into a Death Camp..."

Share |

A somewhat uncomfortable tempest is brewing in Germany about the Holocaust. (I wonder how many times you could write that in a year.) The debate is over whether the German national soccer team, which is heading to Poland soon for Euro 2012, should take some time out of its training schedule this summer to visit Auschwitz. After all, the English team is going.

The debate itself is actually sort of complicated. Nobody seems to oppose the idea that it would be good for German team to pay its respects, to acknowledge the Holocaust, etc. etc. But wouldn’t a public visit by a soccer team actually be sort of disingenuous? Obviously the last thing anybody wants to do is exploit the Holocaust for the sake of public relations. (This is the part where Norman Finkelstein’s ears perk up and he jumps on his bicycle and pedals frantically all the way to Berlin, loose leafs of paper covered in conspiratorial scribbles trailing in the wind behind him.)

Henryk Broder, a.k.a. the last remaining German Jewish writer, has spoken out against the visit. Here’s a longish excerpt from his column in Der Spiegel:

What are the footballers supposed to do in Auschwitz? Swear that they're sorry? Explain that this sort of thing can "never happen again?" And has anyone thought about what would happen if the German players visited Auschwitz and became so overcome by emotion that they lost the tournament?

It isn't about the players visiting Auschwitz. It's about the images of the visit that will be broadcast to the rest of the world afterwards -- as if they were touring an SOS Children's Village in Africa to draw the world's attention to the misery of war orphans.

His last point, about the images being broadcast to the rest of the world, is petty, insular, and needlessly insecure about public perception of the Holocaust. First of all, global awareness of the Holocaust isn’t at stake here -- people have basically made up their minds about it and Germans been pretty forthright in their gestures of public remorse. Getting worked up about the possibility that dead Jews will look like victims? Well, it’s kind of late for that. And to not realize that the genocide of millions of people is much, much bigger than a 10-second voiceover segment on the BBC news strikes me as myopic to an absurd degree.

The parties seem to have settled on a compromise: The German team will visit, but not publicly because, as The Guardian puts it, “the visit should be made out of respect to the victims, rather than as a public spectacle.”

In the span of a few articles we’ve managed to turn a soccer tournament into a comedy of manners about the Holocaust...well done, everybody. Even generations removed from Nazism, German public figures and public organizations are trapped: They have to demonstrate not only remorse, but the right amount of remorse, delivered at the appropriate somber, but not overly somber pitch. Don’t be so public about it, but don’t be too shy to say something. The result is statements like this overly obvious and clearly uncomfortable gem from Wolfgang Neirsbach, president of the German Football Association:

"I myself have already been to Auschwitz and I know from my own experience how much the memory of the Holocaust is important."

One can only imagine what Mr. Neirsbach would say if confronted with something truly complex, like the prospect of his best player, Mesut Ozil, whose grandparents immigrated to Germany from Turkey, visiting Auschwitz as part of a mournful German delegation, while meanwhile Ozil’s own ancestral homeland, which continues to have an exceedingly close relationship with Germany, has yet to even blink in the direction of the genocide it committed of over a million Armenians.

“I myself have been to Turkey and I know from my own experience how much the memory of...nevermind.”

For the visual learners, this Turkish shampoo commercial featuring Adolf Hitler sums thing up:

Share |

Comments

This blog is a first class work, It is indeed a classic work of art.
Car Bluetooth

a

This is certainly as well a really good posting we seriously experienced looking through. It is far from on a daily basis we have risk to check out a little something. https://www.facebook.com/enrico.toldo.142

cbd vape oil
a site serving as a gathering point for anyone interested or involved in intellectual property issues that may impact F/OSS efforts, is now up and running. All are welcome to drop by and to contribute! Jeff Causey

cbd vape oil
a site serving as a gathering point for anyone interested or involved in intellectual property issues that may impact F/OSS efforts, is now up and running. All are welcome to drop by and to contribute! Jeff Causey

Because of this it will be significantly better which you could suitable studies just before manufacturing. You'll be able to create significantly greater guide that way. See this information

Swiftly this amazing site may well irrefutably turn out to be well-known between almost all writing a blog men and women, as a result of thorough content and even assessments. More Info

Swiftly this amazing site may well irrefutably turn out to be well-known between almost all writing a blog men and women, as a result of thorough content and even assessments. More Info

I might suggest almost any information. It really is superb to see you might reveal with text by heart as well as display quality by using precious information is reasonably purely known. sri lanka kite school

Thanks for sharing nice information with us. i like your post and all you share with us is uptodate and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.
Carolineis11

The look rightly terrific. All these mini advice happen to be created implementing massive amount past working experience. I'd like to see the whole works very much. redirected here

I really like your personal submit. It is excellent to find out an individual clarify within phrases within the middle in addition to lucidity relating to this important subject might be effortlessly observed. this article

This is certainly what's more a good report that i definitely enjoyed reading reviewing. It is actually no regularly that i contain the risk to discover a specific thing. info

I enjoy kinds very own post. It'll be respectable to get a single describe inside terms from the central and also chastity on this distinct essential specialized niche will probably be commonly knowledgeable. Great Fortnite Videos

Swiftly this web site can unquestionably become popular between almost all blogging and site-building folks, due to its meticulous posts or perhaps critiques. แทงบอลเงินสด

Swiftly this web site can irrefutably become popular between almost all blogging and site-building folks, because thorough posts or perhaps critiques. boat trips Trogir

I will give you 80 NICHE Relevant Blog Comments safe and effective for your site to Rank on Google and other Search Engine. You get 80 HIgh Quality NICHE Relevent Blog Comments in a 3 days for only in 5$.  Niche Relevant Blog Comments

this is this kind of beatific resource which you are providing and you come back to an goodwill it away for forgive. I hero worship seeing weblog that acquire the price of presenting a mood useful resource for clean. Pecsamusichall

thank you due to the fact you've got been first-class to allocation tell once us. we will continually respect all you have got curtains right here due to the fact I recognize you're each one concerned next to our. Mavys Jewels

I love the numerous blogposts, We critically loved, I'd like information about this, because it is quite fantastic., Regards regarding indicating. tile installation Birmingham MI

whats up, this weekend is delightful for me, by means of now this era i'm analyzing this big informative article right here at my habitat. Trigona.se

when your internet site or weblog goes live for the first become antiquated, it's miles thrilling. that is till you do no person but you and your. Fortnite aimbot

we are in fact thankful in your weblog declare. you will locate a lot of approaches after journeying your screen. i was exactly attempting to find. thanks for such say and make smile shop it taking region. incredible take steps. top 10 dating sites

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. latest news

When i provided for your webpage whilst making attraction easily just a bit tad submits. Entertaining technique for continued, Shoreline Amphitheatre tickets I'll be book-marking before starting find choices finished is available " up ".

Its wonderful as your other content , thank you for posting. car detailing

I really like all of the articles, I truly loved, I'd like more info relating to this, simply because it's very good., Many thanks with regard to discussing. Free Nursing CEUs

Everybody loves most of the conversations, We really skilled, I would choose more information when it comes to this particular, because it's amazing., Along with because of obtain distributing. paper folding

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. cara melacak pemilik nomor hp lewat internet

I like all the content articles, I really cherished, I would like more information concerning this, due to the fact it is extremely great., Thank you regarding talking about. http://www.origami-make.org

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. cheap essay services

A luxurious blog, truth be told. Appreciated every tiny bit of this amazing thing.
cheap monthly seo plan

What is an outstanding post! “I’ll be back” (to read more of your content). Thanks for the nudge! pay for essay

It is a fantastic post – immense clear and easy to understand. I am also holding out for the sharks too that made me laugh. pomeranian boo fiyat

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this... pkv games

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please keep it up. Great work. buy google accounts

This kind of booklet always inspiring and i select to go online mood content material, for that excuse glad to find great region to many here in the proclaim, the writing is just on your liking, thank you for the name. Soundwiz

A blog that is so immaculate, fortunate to peruse it.
BUY WEBSITE TRAFFIC

thank you due to the fact you've got been first-class to allocation tell once us. we will continually respect all you have got curtains right here due to the fact I recognize you're each one concerned next to our. jamb result

whats up, this weekend is delightful for me, by means of now this era i'm analyzing this big informative article right here at my habitat. lipo laser

I admire some thing you have introduced to my know-how base.Admiring the emerge as antiquated and effort you put into your weblog and detailed reference you pay for.thanks. CB01

I admire some thing you have introduced to my know-how base.Admiring the emerge as antiquated and effort you put into your weblog and detailed reference you pay for.thanks. CB01

we are in fact thankful in your weblog declare. you will locate a lot of approaches after journeying your screen. i was exactly attempting to find. thanks for such say and make smile shop it taking region. incredible take steps. iptv

I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I Always prefer to read The Quality and glad I found this thing in you post. Thanks Cpi certification nursing

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this... http://worldpokerchips.club

I really appreciate the kind of topics you post here. Thanks for sharing us a great information that is actually helpful. Good day! craigslist ad poster

I am impressed. I don't think Ive met anyone who knows as much about this subject as you do. You are truly well informed and very intelligent. You wrote something that people could understand and made the subject intriguing for everyone. Really, great blog you have got here. dog grooming nyc

I portt any phrase to understand this pronounce.....really i'm impressed from this publicize....the person who make this claim it became a pleasurable human..thank you for shared this in the back of than us. 토토사이트

You made such an interesting piece to read, giving every subject enlightenment for us to gain knowledge. Thanks for sharing the such information with us to read this... 123movies free

I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. I am hoping the same best work from you in the future as well. Thanks... 123moviesgo