Making It Work: On Baseball's Heel Deficit

Share |

 

We are past the hot-take moment, the pearls are un-clutched, and some sort of on-field reckoning is comfortably in sight. Whatever it was that people thought or are still thinking about Richard Sherman's incendiary 29-second postgame interview after the NFC Conference Championship is fading into what they think he will do on the field in the Super Bowl. This is a relief, for reasons you already know.

It seems, too, as if there has been a sort of weary recognition, among all but the sport's crustiest observers, that Sherman’s personality is good for the game of football. It helps that he's both great and great fun to watch, but Sherman's dedication to the big and brash has raised stakes not just for the Super Bowl, but for less-significant games to come. His words and actions will have every quarterback and top wide receiver on the Seahawks’ schedule next year, especially a certain 49ers receiver named Crabtree, aiming to beat him, to get back at his words through their play, to outperform him. This is all good, and all more or less harmless. Baseball would never allow it.

Justin Verlander, for one, was not having it. “So [Seahawks QB] Russell [Wilson] is a class act!  Sherman on the other hand," Verlander tweeted. "If he played baseball would get a high and tight fastball.” Here is one of baseball’s best pitchers taking a stand—on Twitter, but bear with me—against any and all who would deign to express pride or react positively in the immediate moments following three hours of consecutive adrenaline rushes and one of the biggest plays of his professional life. That person gets hit with a baseball. Who’s to say baseball is any less meatheaded or overly aggro than football?

This is not just Verlander, and his anti-expression hard-assery reflects a bigger problem. Baseball is doing its damnedest to let its self-policing run amok, to corral and discourage any and all showings of positive emotion it deems unruly, and that percentage seems to be on the rise every year.

There is new Yankees catcher Brian McCann who, then still with the Braves and after Brewers outfielder Carlos Gomez hit a homer and yapped his way around the bases, lowered himself to Gomez’s level by actually preventing Gomez from touching home plate. This isn’t quite apples to apples with Sherman, because Gomez was clearly being an antagonist and acting less out of pure pride than with a desire to rub it in the Braves' collective face, and specifically that of pitcher Paul Maholm, who beaned Gomez with a pitch in a game in June. But the league’s disciplinary action in the aftermath was an affirmation of Verlander’s threat in a different form.

Both benches cleared in that Braves/Brewers tilt, with one pseudo-blow being thrown and landed by Braves outfielder Reed Johnson. There was scuffling, but the action level was more on par with a shoving match outside a bar on a Wednesday than, say, The Rumble in the Jungle, or even the bruising theater of the Royal Rumble. Gomez did not throw a punch nor, as far as is discernible, participate beyond words and be carried along with the wave of the brouhaha. He was suspended for one game, as was Johnson. McCann and Braves first baseman Freddie Freeman were fined, not suspended; it was hard not to read it as an implicit approval of McCann’s actions. Gomez was a yapping dork and got a game; McCann literally interfered with the operation of the game and got tapped on the wrist.

All of this works in lockstep with all of baseball’s “unwritten rules,” an amorphous and invisible code of conduct enforced when players get their feelings hurt. Look at a home run for more than 1.5 seconds? Get a spherical bruise next time you step in the box. Pump your fist and and let out an exclamatory yell after getting a big strikeout to end an inning? Get a scolding by some crusty baseball cop. This is a willful neutering of the game's emotional range, but it's also a sort of ham-fisted brand management. Players can let loose and have a little fun, just as long as it’s part of a production for MLB’s Fan Cave video series and not on the field. It is nearly impossible to imagine something as benignly berserk—or consciously theatrical—as Sherman's outburst even happening in a baseball context. Some glowering McCann interrupts the very thought of it.

***

Players often claim that “respect for the game” is in their best interests, and that often comes up whenever someone loses the plot and violates one of those unwritten rules. But whose respect is really on the line, here? Pitchers have a uniquely vulnerable role on the field, but also the power to dangle threats of bodily harm, like Verlander. This instinct to go a-plunking is more cowardly than protective, a bit of tough posing that also happens to be a way to avoid the risk of getting beat again by the guy who swagged out against you in his last at-bat. Turning shame-based hurt feelings into retributive violence is a strange and reactive definition of "respect," by any standard.

Literal, physical hitting back isn't built into baseball the way it is in football, but the threat of retaliation—which is not new, but does have a new huffiness about it—has done much more to homogenize baseball than it has football. It certainly has denied the sport its Richard Sherman, which is a shame.

Baseball’s most polarizing figures these days are usually entwined in disciplinary battles with the league, in court or through righteous press releases—think of Barry Bonds, Alex Rodriguez, Roger Clemens, Ryan Braun. It's not just that this doesn't look good on the players or the game. There is, inherently, no fun in it.

What the game could use—not what it needs, an important distinction—is another Rickey Henderson. We might get only one Rickey per lifetime, but it doesn't seem too much to ask for a player whose skills, production and personality stand proudly above par, with an outsized personality to match. Henderson was not universally admired, but he was universally acknowledged as great, and his talent was equaled only by his braggadocio. “I am a creator,” he once told the Newburgh-Beacon Evening News in 1986, at age 27. “I want to make things happen, and I want to make them happen with style. I like to do things differently.” There are players who might think this way, but few who would say as much, let alone play with the swagger that would bring it off. The ones who would dare to do so will dodge fastballs for their trouble.

Baseball will survive and thrive if no such player emerges in the near future, of course, but this is a mold worth breaking all the same. And wouldn't it be grand if someone broke the mold? Wouldn’t it be grander still if pitchers, instead of headhunting in reaction to this hypothetical player’s outspoken nature, simply tried their best to get him out? Who could begrudge them a fist-pump or two, if they pulled it off.

Share |

Comments

Good website! I truly love how it is easy on my eyes it is. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day! Read More

thank you this is excellent blog. Read More

thank you this is excellent blog. Read More

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article. דילים מטורפים

Took me time to read all the comments, but I really enjoyed the article. It proved to be Very helpful to me and I am sure to all the commenters here! It’s always nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! טיולים מאורגנים

I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work... נופש לחנוכה

I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! keep up the good work... java homework assignments

thanks this is good blog. math homework help

What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. chemistry solver

What a fantabulous post this has been. Never seen this kind of useful post. I am grateful to you and expect more number of posts like these. Thank you very much. economics assignment help

thanks thoroughly a whole lot for this beneficial article. I at the back of it. private detectives

When you use a genuine service, you will be able to provide instructions, share materials and choose the formatting style. construction Risk management consultancy Liverpool

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. engineering homework help

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. statistic homework help

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work. physic homework help

I further to your pronounce. it's far secure to peer you verbalize from the coronary heart and readability next to citation to this critical difficulty can be without problems observed... voyance amour

simply I experience your web page furthermore practising and beneficial opinion. it is protected enormously handy calculation as soon as a variety of our assets.thanks for element. i enjoy this make acknowledged. buy Bitcoin with Skrill

when your internet site or weblog goes live for the first become antiquated, it's miles thrilling. that is till you do no person but you and your. Graduation stole

This particular papers astounding, and My spouse and that i enjoy every of the take impact which you have placed into this. Im firm that you'll be making a in truth useful area. I has been moreover deferential. exact play-success! kente stole

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you. android app development company

yes i'm wholly in reality later this article and that i simply throb proclaim that this newsletter is absolutely possible and truely informative article.i will make particular to be reading your weblog more. You made a pure mitigation however I cannot designate dispel to however astonishment, what approximately the brand new facet? !!!!!!thanks Casino Malaysia

I just couldn't go away your website to the front telling you that I in fact loved the height character information you difficult employee for your visitors? will be with returned again regularly to test taking vicinity about some other posts. Salt lamp

Enjoyed every bit of your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool. yacht charter europe

i've gate your article, it's far intensely informative and beneficial for me.I esteem the important mention you manage to pay for on your articles. thanks for posting it.. australian assignment help

Very tempting weblog. Alot of blogs I see nowadays do not in fact proclaim yes some thing that i'm eager in, but i am maximum definately keen in this one. simply idea that i might statement and set aside you realize. australian assignment help

Wow, proud kingdom. i would at the back of to jot down as soon as this too - taking era and concrete hard play a position to make a cozy article... however I put things off too much and by no means appear to earnings began. thank you even though. assignment help

thank you for a super allocation. Your article has proved your difficult produce an impact and experience you've got were given on this showground. top notch .i be ashore on it studying. skyadboard global network information

It changed into wondering if I may want to use this write-taking area regarding my supplementary website, i can member it backing taking region in your website although.notable thanks. skyadboard global network information

awesome article Lot's of opinion to read...fantastic man keep Posting and replace to human beings..thank you Salt lamp

awesome article Lot's of opinion to read...fantastic man keep Posting and replace to human beings..thank you essay writing service

Took me technology to entre all of the observations, however I absolutely loved the article. It proved to be Very cordial to me and i am unconditional to all the commenters here! Its constantly clean whilst you can't on your own be informed, however with entertained! forbes magazine

Took me technology to entre all of the observations, however I absolutely loved the article. It proved to be Very cordial to me and i am unconditional to all the commenters here! Its constantly clean whilst you can't on your own be informed, however with entertained! education

What a fantabulous observe this has been. in no way seen this understandable of beneficial claim. i'm grateful to you and assume more quantity of posts at the side of those. thank you intensely a lot. טיסה זולה

What a fantabulous observe this has been. in no way seen this understandable of beneficial claim. i'm grateful to you and assume more quantity of posts at the side of those. thank you intensely a lot. Online business ideas

I wanted to thank you for this in your liking ensnare!! I particularly enjoying all tiny little bit of it I have you ever bookmarked to check out delivered stuff you pronounce. long haircuts girl

This particular papers astounding, and My spouse and that i enjoy every of the take impact which you have placed into this. Im firm that you'll be making a in truth useful area. I has been moreover deferential. exact play-success! private investigator Singapore

in case you are searching out extra advocate very about flat fee locksmith Las Vegas take a look at that proper away. Gud Nyt Pics

This is a top 10 ragnarok online private server thats high on the list and top ranking with massive players online. ragnarok private server

Wow, What a high-quality claim. I in reality found this to a good deal informatics. it's miles what i was looking for.i would subsequent to to the lead taking vicinity through now the child guide for advice you that hold amused keep sharing such kind of data.thank you open gmail account

interesting challenge for a weblog. i've been searching the net for fun and got here re your internet site. gorgeous pronounce. thank you a ton for sharing your knowledge! it is exciting to look that some people but complement an attempt into coping with their websites. i'll be actual to check Truecaller apk

Thanks for providing recent updates regarding the concern, I look forward to read more. سكس

that is my first visit on your web magazine! we're a outfit of volunteers and subsidiary sports in the equal distinctiveness. internet site gave us helpful records to court engagement. Silsila Badalte Rishton Ka

i was surfing the internet for recommendation and got here across your blog. i am inspired by the safety you've got in economic credit to this weblog. It indicates how ably you come occurring at the back of the cash for this difficulty. affordable papers

we have sell some merchandise of rotate custom boxes.it's far absolutely useful and completely low fee allure visits this web page thanks and appeal component this say thinking of your links. website

Thanks for a wonderful share. Your article has proved your hard work and experience you have got in this field. Brilliant .i love it reading. VIP FINANCING SOLUTIONS REVIEWS

Love to read it,Waiting For More new Update and I Already Read your Recent Post its Great Thanks. Dil Hi To Hai

fine web page, in which did u come happening long gone the opinion with reference to this posting?i have right of access most of the articles regarding your internet site now, and i in fact plus your style. thank you 1,000,000 and soak up save happening the vigorous deed. dlf crest

thank you for a super allocation. Your article has proved your difficult produce an impact and experience you've got were given on this showground. top notch .i be ashore on it studying. iphone flashing tool

Thanks for a fantastic allocation. Your article has proved your hard produce an effect and experience you have got in this showground. Brilliant .i be ashore on it reading. e zigarette

Thanks for a fantastic allocation. Your article has proved your hard produce an effect and experience you have got in this showground. Brilliant .i be ashore on it reading. Dating expert taratova1985