Going West

Share |

Chase Field in Phoenix and Seattle’s Safeco Field are perhaps the quintessential examples of what retractable-roof stadiums should be: baseball-only parks with roofs that are used regularly, and built specifically, to respond to their respective town’s beautiful - if unpredictable - climates.

From the intense heat and random dust storms of the American Southwest to the wild and sudden tempests of the Pacific Northwest, the locations these stadiums find themselves require the most ingenuous engineering and agile grounds crews.

Whether or not such solid planning has flowed from building management to team management is up for debate. The troubles have stayed on the field for the Mariners, who went from tying the all-time record for wins in their 3rd season in the park to finishing under .500 for seven of the last nine years; while the Arizona Diamondbacks, seem to have less difficulty staying competitive in between the lines, if not necessarily the box office.

Chase Field debuted the same day the Diamondbacks did, opening in 1998 the day team began play. Created using the designs of Kansas City-based Ellerbe Becket, Chase Field is located in downtown Phoenix where it towers over the neighborhood as one of MLB’s tallest stadiums.

Part of the reason for the stadium’s height is its unique roof. Relying on drawbridge technology with its two-part roof, when opened each half remains to the east and west of the north-south oriented field and come together above centerfield when closed; the highly unusual design a result of frequent Phoenix dust storms requiring the roof to be as simple and gear-free as possible. These restraints forced designers to use an extensive network of cables to close the roof, instead of the cogs and tracks found in its five counterparts.

A patchwork of red brick, green and white metal panels, exposed structural steel, glass and Diamondback signage highlight the stadium’s exterior, which breaks down the enormous scale of the rectangle-shaped stadium and creates an atmosphere more ‘Arizona modern’ than old-timey baseball.

Inside, Chase Field does have some gimmicky features, like the infamous swimming pool beyond the centerfield wall, where $3,500 gets you a night’s rental.  But overall, the stadium feels much less traditional than other modern-retro parks, especially its not-so-small-stadium-feel 48,000 capacity. The effect is compounded by the fact that most seats are between the foul poles, pushing upper decks to some of the loftiest heights in baseball.  Overall, the roof and building feel well integrated at Chase Field and the effect is a fairly cohesive, modern baseball stadium.

However, fairly cohesive and modern has not exactly brought in the crowds, as the D’backs have finished outside the top 10 in NL attendance for the last 7 years after their first six years as an organization. For context, their expansion twins, the Tampa Bay Rays, have finished in the top 10 only once, two years after their dramatic run to the World Series in their 14 years of existence.

What’s odd is that their record likely doesn’t play much of a factor in this, as the ups and downs for the Diamondbacks have been less pronounced that teams such as the Astros and Mariners -- whose struggles since moving we’ll look at later. That’s not to say they’ve been to the playoffs much recently -- making it in only two of the last ten seasons (when they began a rebuilding process following the departure of many of the members of the 2001 World Series team) -- they’ve finished over .500 half those times.

While the true reason behind the drop in attendance is hard to pinpoint, and as any number of factors could have led to the decline, given the BoB/Chase Field’s lackluster performance in most relevant rankings of the sport’s parks, it seems that the organization may want to start there.

Safeco Field opened a year after Chase Field in 1999, replacing the colossal, concrete Kingdome which had housed Mariner baseball and Seahawk football since the late 1970’s. Like true urban ballparks of the past, Safeco Field conforms to a city block in downtown Seattle. The main entrance to the park is at the corner of 1st Avenue South and Edgar Martinez Drive South and, although it feels more Barnes & Noble bookshop than stadium, the cylinder through which you enter is a nice feature and a true link to urban ballparks of the past.  

Safeco Field sits within the SoDo warehouse district of Seattle, adjacent to Puget Sound.  It’s therefore no surprise that the exterior is a mix of red brick, exposed structural steel and glass.  This decision feels right, if uninspired, given its particular setting in the city.

Unlike those parks with the most similar roofs, Miller and Minute Maid, Safeco Field is never totally sealed to the elements.  When closed, the roof functions like an umbrella, the sides of the park remain open to rain and wind, which makes it, along with Seibu Dome in Japan, only one of two such covered baseball stadiums in the world.  

Which seems more problematic than it actually is, as despite Seattle’s rainy reputation, the dry summers common in the city means that the team sees some of the lowest total rainfall of any city in Major League Baseball during the season.  In fact the roof was closed for only twelve games this season, making it the most opened of the retractable roof stadiums in baseball. Occasional, prolonged rain forces the closure of the roof to allow the game to proceed, and this just feels like the way a retractable roof should be used; though the lack of integration of the giant roof overhead with the stadium below feels like an oversight.  

It hasn’t seem to have bothered fans, however, as last year was the first to not see the Mariners in the top 10 in attendance since their arrival at Safeco, despite some truly putrid seasons of recent vintage. Which, is not surprising given Seattle’s reputation as an intense and intensely loyal fan base, but could become problematic for the Mariners in the future, especially if the decline in attendance turns into a trend.

Which is a possibility, if troubles in the front office haven’t been fixed. The team severely lacks in major star power -- outside of the organization’s crown jewel, pitcher Felix Hernandez. The squad must still figure out how to mitigate the intense effects the best pitchers’ park in either league -- allowing .687 the amount of runs of other parks, for a park factor score of 91 (>100 good for hitters/<100 good for pitchers) -- has on the production of its own batters. 

Bloated contracts for players either not suited for the park -- like in-any-year-other-than-this-one MVP candidate and Rangers 3B Adrian Beltre -- or baseball -- like never-in-any-year-an MVP candidate Richie Sexson have haunted the franchise for years. Until recently, shrewd moves such as a trading away an unhappy Ichiro to and acquiring catcher Jesus Montero from the Yankees for injured P Michael Pineda in two separate deals, were the ones being done to the Mariners. 

What these inconsistencies between stadium design, team performance and attendance perhaps illustrate is the degree to which architecture can or cannot change human behavior.  In Seattle, where large numbers of people live in or near the downtown area the Mariners playing is a nice event during summer months whether or not the M’s are playing good baseball.  A well designed alternative to the Kingdome put M’s games on the list of “things to do” in Seattle.  While in Arizona, summers bring both intense heat and reduced populations of fleeing snowbird communities lead to minimal attendance records exacerbated by poor performance by D’backs.  Regardless of how well composed the Chase Field façade is or how well the roof and mechanical systems control the indoor climate, there is only so much architecture can do to bring lukewarm fans out to the game save giving tickets away.

Matthew Brown is an architect who writes about stadia and sport venues past and present on his own blog and Twitter.

Infographics by Nick Bond

Share |

Comments

I just gazed all the way up your website just because May very well been told such a lot of on the subject of a items. graphic design cincinnati ohio

I also benefit from learning the assessments, but learn that alot of people ought to stay on essay to try and add worth in the direction of the authentic weblog release.
CBS Formula Review

One of many blogs online, I like reading through your own probably the most a person provide all of us a lot data in a single little item. pot stocks

You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant!MicrodermaMitt

Much thanks for composing such an intriguing article on this point. This has truly made me think and I plan to peruse more. emergency tree removal atlanta ga

Individuals quite messed others " up " go on semester. Pertaining to any customers receive pay attention to and additionally keep on shut off the software. songs pk

thanks for the tips and information..i really appreciate it..website

201X Store is a fashion online free-to-watch need-to-buy site where we provide you fresh designs that could adjust to any customer’s requirement, no matter the topic (sports, games, cartoons, chilling or just a cup of coffee at the moonlight).Hipster t-shirts

I discovered your this post while looking for data about web journal related exploration ... assurance voiture électrique

You have a decent point here!I absolutely concur with what you have said!!Thanks for sharing your views...hope more individuals will read this article!!! his secret obsession

This is exactly equally an excellent content i quite really liked checking. This isn't all the time which i possess potential to work out an issue. Penny Millionaire

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.Gut Gardens

Remember to proceed this specific wonderful operate along with My spouse and i expect additional of your respective wonderful web sites. Android Application Development

Wonderful web page plus the remarkable superior quality thing and additionally I’m of course this is really important. game reviews

Great weblog combined with the superb high quality things as well as I’m certain this is significantly useful. Nasdaq Inside Trader

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free.property management companies New Orleans

Satisfy persist it very good get the job done and even As i watch for alot more from your remarkable articles or content. Rak Company Formation

What we realized can be appropriate, recognize you must separate your connect involving active tangible along with brand-new. You have to be mindful if you take care of your tangible with the partitions, since in any other case you will find there's possibility to separate. It usually is greater to have the support associated with an pro. How To Make Money Online Fast

Once i received onto your website even though getting consideration basically somewhat tad submits. Pleasurable strategy for upcoming, I am bookmarking at the same time acquire kinds end rises upwards. The Royce Code Review

Reading through your own weblogs can make me personally wish to create increasingly more. Parrandas Vallenatas Cali

This is exceedingly informatics, fresh and clear. I believe that everything has been portrayed in methodical way with the goal that peruser could get most extreme data and realize numerous things. inz residence

Wonderful web page plus the remarkable superior quality thing and additionally I’m of course this is really important. penomet cheap

Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!http://evergreenfamilydental.com/

Terrific blog you possess in this case, such a lot of fascinating advice!.. http://www.6em-sens.fr

Together with thank you for anyone supporting website you might have actually recently been creating. I needed shied away from creating comments since media received about currently. Criação de sites

There are several dissertation internet sites on line because you get evidently reported as part of your web site. Aashiqui 2 Songs

Any blog really are awesome! You've gotten conditioned others which i may well come up with as cool as Document truly reckoned We can. URINARY TRACT INFECTION

Genital herpes virus treatments appreciated is normally most suitable, figure out you might want to burst all the reconnect approximately old concrete saw faq and additionally cutting edge. You'll want to be very careful as soon as you combat all the concrete saw faq inside the wall structure, as if you don't the good news is chance to burst. The first couple more suitable to acquire the benefit on the guru. affordable jewelry

Good blog along with the excellent quality stuff and I’m sure this will be greatly helpful. weight training

Please continue this great work and I look forward to more of your awesome blogs. Axis Condos

Delight maintain this approach awesome succeed and additionally Document wait for a great deal more on your stunning blog posts. fish store

Výborný příspěvek, jste vždycky nějaké velké druh projektů s tebou, jsem viděl dřevostavby na svém blogu, který dělal mě přemýšlet o najímání vás brzy mého domu.
`

Most certainly, this unique gained everybody reasoning how many other training are actually acceptable for some of those sufferers what individuals see personally out of the office and / or need reasonably limited hardware methods. CCcam

Promptly this url might unquestionably end up legendary in between every writing many people, due to the meticulous articles and reviews and ratings. blockeddrainssutherlandshire.com.au

Immediately this blog is going to indisputably often be prominent concerning all of blog people today, because of fastidious reports and also assessments.

Excellent website combined with outstanding top quality products and also I’m positive this will be tremendously beneficial. Seaside Residences Frasers

When i simply want to inform you about i always simply just look into your web site in addition to When i realize its incredibly useful in addition to beneficial.. شحن الراجحي موقع خمسات

Utilizing kudos for people being able to help webpage you will have extremely happen to be earning. I saw it shied out earning feed-back mainly because current information have approximately now. songs

Utilizing kudos for people being able to help webpage you will have extremely happen to be earning. I saw it shied out earning feed-back mainly because current information have approximately now. Parrandon Vallenato Cali

My husbabd and I planned a trip to Dubai. We wanted it to be perfect so we contacted www.desertsafaridubaii.com they took us to the most special dubai places. We had the amazing tour all because of this company

As i bought onto your web site nevertheless positioning focus purely a little bit little submits. Satisfying strategy for foreseeable future, I will be bookmarking each time receive people finish off arises in place. Parrandon Cali

Document was aware of the fact that impact was first only just all the foreign language benefit from it also yet seemed problematic. At this time it’s definitely do- effective. With thanks for those support. Jual MSI gaming

This is the best blog of this year. The information is priceless. And the font you've used is pure class. Great job done here! forceboost

Mate, you are absolutely right here. Great article! Force Boost

I've been to the old one and the new one as well. And I can say that the new one is better, not just because there are more seats. It's more comfortable than the previous one.
Atlanta SEO

I conclude I have selected the smart and inconceivable website along with interesting stuff.best insurance comapanies for whole life insurance cost

I agree. You have made the nice blogs with the great info in the contents. virginia online payday loans

Fine method of telling, and enjoyable article to acquire factual statements.online loans