Dissenting With The Dissenter: A reply to Dave Zirin on the NBA Finals

Share |

Dave Zirin is one of our truly great and legitimately relevant sports journalists. His articles for The Nation about the politics and ethics behind the games first introduced me (among many other readers) to a wider view of sports, and engaged me as a politically conscious—and therefore often and inevitably conflicted—sports fan, and gave nuance and complexity to what most other sports journalism otherwise largely represents as a pretty homogenous and boneheaded cultural arena. He remains the most reliably progressive voice in sports commentary, raising questions plenty of people would rather not ask, let alone answer.

A perennial theme to these questions is the frequent and unpleasant contradiction between the game [choose your sport] and its ugly industry, and this is the banner under which Zirin has sounded the call against the Oklahoma City Thunder. Those Thunder's appearance in the upcoming NBA Finals against the Miami Heat, has, as Zirin blogged today, has been cast as a competition between good (Thunder) and evil (Heat). This is, according to Zirin, ass-backwards:

With such seemingly opposite teams and stars, the media are already writing the 2012 finals script of “good vs. evil.” It’s an easy, by-the-numbers narrative. It’s also bizarro world bullshit. This is one case where good is evil and the evil in question resides in shadows where fans choose not to look.

I would argue that how we choose to see the Heat and Thunder is a litmus test. It’s a litmus test that reveals how the sports radio obsession with villainizing twenty-first-century athletes blinds us to the swelling number of villains who inhabit the owner’s box. And in Oklahoma City, we have the kinds of sports owners whose villainy should never be forgotten.

… [Thunder owners] Clay Bennett and Aubrey McClendon don’t deserve anyone’s cheers. I don’t just want the Thunder to lose. I want LeBron James to make them wish they’d never left the Emerald City.

But simply flipping the script can’t be the answer, or at least seems like a bit of easy contrarianism unworthy of Zirin. LeBron James, Dwyane Wade and Chris Bosh aren’t playing Clay Bennett, Aubrey McClendon and David Stern. They’re playing Kevin Durant, Russell Westbrook and James Harden. Rooting for the players of one team to win an ideological battle, however righteous, against the owners of another doesn’t add up.

The difficulty is that while sports appear in the cultural arena as a part of civil society, and while we apparently participate in them—as fans, as observers, as journalists and tweeters—our participation isn’t democratic. “Rooting for” is not “voting for,” since owners follow the money, not fans’ input. See: the gilded Maloof hooves stampeding away from Sacramento; or the one that motivates Zirin’s (and other thoughtful people’s) anti-Thunder stance, the Seattle Sonics’ move to Oklahoma City.

In fact, given that all candidates in actual American elections follow the money, and that one such has called himself the future “CEO of America,” it would probably be better to say “rooting for” Mitt Romney/Obama/their Super PACs than “voting for” them. “Rooting for” anything implies a wishful attitude, a well-wishing for people or things with which you identify but upon whose fate you have no actual impact. This is why it is a term so well suited for sports: when the game is in play, fans submit to contingency, not principle.

But, of course, sports are an industry off the field or diamond or court or pitch. If fans want empowerment, there ought to be ways to affect that with regard to how the business of sports is conducted. Plenty of writers, Zirin foremost among them, have advocated this. But it seems like a category mistake to say that, in an actual game or series, you should root for or against players, as individuals or as a team, because you do or don’t like the way their owners handled their business. Zirin makes this point himself about the Miami Heat, after all: LeBron’s transfer was mismanagement; don’t hate the players, hate the corporate game. Fair enough, but why, then, doesn’t the same logic apply to OKC? We can’t root against LeBron for bygone industry blunders, but rooting against the Thunder is an ethical obligation for anyone who rejects unaccountable ownership and craven management decisions.

Rooting against a team because you despise the dirty dealings of the franchise implies the false belief that a series or game loss would somehow directly impact the ethics and politics of the way its owners do business. That’s not how change happens, at least not in sports, at least not today. Rooting against the Thunder or Miami in the NBA Finals might be, in principle, a righteous stand against the business. In reality, though, it isn’t an effective vote against their owners.

Share |

Comments

Astounding .. Astonishing .. I'll bookmark your web journal and take the bolsters additionally… I'm upbeat to discover such a large number of valuable information here in the post, we require work out more methods in such manner, a debt of gratitude is in order for sharing. loftplan liquidation

A debt of gratitude is in order for the post and incredible tips..even I additionally believe that diligent work is the most essential part of getting achievement..
bobbleheads

I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work. its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favoriteI just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. werbeartikel duesseldorf

Fascinating and stunning how your post is! It Is Useful and accommodating for me That I like it all that much, and I am anticipating Hearing from your next.. Phoenix SEO

Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article.
bobbleheads

A debt of gratitude is in order for setting aside an ideal opportunity to talk about this, I feel firmly about it and love adapting more on this subject. key phrases

I just found this blog and have high hopes for it to continue. Keep up the great work. its hard to find good ones. I have added to my favorites. Thank You Wicked Web Design

I would be glad if all WebPages provided such type of best articles.
forskolin

This is very informatics, fresh and clear. I feel that everything has been depicted in efficient way with the goal that peruser could get most extreme data and realize numerous things. rehab

This is a savvy blog. I would not joke about this. You have such a great amount of learning about this issue, thus much energy. You additionally know how to make individuals rally behind it, clearly from the reactions. Mexico insurance

This is profoundly informatics, fresh and clear. I imagine that everything has been portrayed in deliberate way so peruser could get most extreme data and realize numerous things. loftplan

Much thanks to you for exceptionally usefull data.. Legal Weed

It is an extraordinary site.. The Design looks great.. Continue working like that!. van hire london

There is good reason why among many sport fishing enthusiasts, Los Suenos and Costa Rica Dreams Sport fishing is considered to best sportfishing destination in the world!
costa rica sport fishing

Pleasant Informative Blog having decent sharing.. Language of Desire

This article gives the light in which we can watch the truth. This is extremely pleasant one and gives indepth data. A debt of gratitude is in order for this pleasant article. blog comments

I truly welcome this great post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would gainful for the majority of the general population. addiction

I truly welcome this great post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would gainful for the majority of the general population. menstrual cup reviews

I truly welcome this great post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would gainful for the majority of the general population. Rehab

Much obliged for the online journal stacked with such a variety of data. Ceasing by your site assisted me with getting what I was searching for. Happy birthday wishes

This is why it is a term so well suited for sports: when the game is in play, fans submit to contingency, not principle.cccam server

Phenomenal site you have here, so much cool data!.. termites

This is really an extraordinary read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am anticipating perusing new articles. Keep doing awesome!. Forever Yours

ought to comment on some broad things, The site style is immaculate, the articles is truly extraordinary : D. Great job, here's to you0800 call forwarding

You finished a couple fine focuses there. I did an inquiry on the subject and discovered about all persons will oblige with your online journal. loft conversions london

This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the conclusion that you are right about many of them. You are great free 0800 numbers

I can't envision concentrating sufficiently long to research; considerably less compose this sort of article. You've beaten yourself with this material. This is extraordinary substance. click here

I think this is a standout amongst the most noteworthy data for me. Also, i'm happy perusing your article. Be that as it may, ought to comment on some broad things, The site style is immaculate, the articles is truly extraordinary : D. Great job, here's to you learn more

I don’t think many of websites provide this type of information. freestanding baths

Howdy dudes! Wonderful stuff protects it up. property managers

I would be pleased if all WebPages provided such articles. neck chiropractic adjustment

You know your activities emerge of the group. There is something extraordinary about them. It appears to me every one of them are truly splendid! read more

I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information. Vinci3D

I really appreciate that you wrote this article and shared some really good information on this specific topic. cheat spouse

I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. It is a great website and nice share. I want to thank you. Good job! You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work fees for private investigator

This is why it is a term so well suited for sports: when the game is in play, fans submit to contingency, not principle.atlanta life coach

i am glad to read the whole content of this blog and am very excited and happy to say that the webmaster has done a very good job here to put all the information content and information... instaforex free forex trading tutorial

You guys do a great blog, and have some great contents. Keep up the good work Singapore private investigator

I truly adored perusing your online journal. It was exceptionally very much created and straightforward. Not at all like different web journals I have perused which are truly not that good.Thanks alot! pirate kings hack cydia

Keep it up; keep posting more n more n more. http://www.loft-conversion-cost.net/

I just couldn't leave your site before letting you know that I genuinely delighted in the top quality information you present to your guests? Will be back again every now and again to determine the status of new posts. loft conversions esssex

I have been looking at a couple of your stories and i can state really well done. I will bookmark your online journal loft conversions twickenham

Good work on this post! I really like the way you delivered your qualitative facts and how you made this fascinating and effortless to realize private investigators fees

Great site! I genuinely adore how it is simple on my eyes it is. I am considering how I may be informed at whatever point another post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trap? Have an extraordinary day! alcohol rehab

Amazing, this is truly fascinating perusing. I am happy I discovered this and got the opportunity to peruse it. Awesome employment on this substance. I like it. drug treatment

Really great post, Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up! high trust flow

Paul Thek and his Circle in the 1950s" examines for the first time Thek as a young man, "placing him within a group of friends and lovers that provided an adoring audience and creative influence for his earliest works," according to a press release. SAME DAY FLOWER DELIVERY UK

quality rugs offering the widest selection in size, colour and services. We believe that every fine rug tells a story and manifests a tradition; it is an investment for generations to come and selecting one should be a tailored fulfilling experience.FLOWERS DELIVERED SAME DAY

I love the character and I am having alot of fun working on it. DC is really awesome to work with I must say. pure natural forskolin

Much obliged for this extraordinary post, i discover it exceptionally fascinating and extremely well thoroughly considered and set up together. I anticipate perusing your work later o sash and case windows edinburgh