What's Missing

Game-canceling NHL chief Gary Bettman is an easy villain, and deserves that status. But he has also reminded fans, in the worst possible way, what the game is worth.
Share |

Before Christopher Nolan made billion-dollar movies about a very rich man angry with the world, he made Following, which is a 70-minute noir that he filmed on 16mm film stock—a far cry from the IMAX cameras Nolan would use for The Dark Knight—and shot on an estimated budget of $6,000. The film was about a floundering writer who follows a thief that doesn’t steal. Instead, he rearranges items, hides jewelry around the house, and places women’s underwear in the apartment in order to incite relationship difficulties.

All sports leagues start off something like Following. Not in terms of the panty-planting or art-stalking, but in the sense that they begin as low-budget entertainments without big names or high hopes; fundamentally, at that point, the leagues are just people mucking about just for the joy of it, if not without some hope of getting paid for it in the future. It's not really innocent, of course. It's just a different type of commerce, if one that's a bit easier to relate to than its mega-sized and metastasized version. Which is what follows, invariably, if the smaller thing works, and grows.

***

The NHL was no exception to this. Forgive this absurdly brief synopsis of the NHL-to-date, but: the league plugged along for its first few decades until it took a hit in the Great Depression/World War II era (who didn’t?) and then aggressively and ambitiously expanded in the 60’s and 70’s (who didn’t?). Unlike Major League Baseball or the NFL currently, it's hard to say the NHL ever had a true Golden Age during which it financially dominated the sports landscape. Even in the Gretzky/Lemieux days, when the hockey stars were brightest and the Great One was the Greatest, it still wasn’t a massive financial payday. You may recall the NBA was going through a Golden Age of its own in the 80’s that took precedent. The defining moment in hockey's U.S. history involves a bunch of college kids in Lake Placid on tape delay. That first miracle has never been matched, and probably never will be.

In 1993, this was all supposed to change. Not in the sense of new miracles, but in the NHL's belated rise into the ranks of the other outlandishly profitable professional sports leagues. Riding the Gretzky-in-Los Angeles wave, Gary Bettman was supposed to accomplish the following goals according to a New York Times article published his first day on the job (with my annotated remarks):

“Put a stop to labor unrest [!!!]; sell the product in television's mainstream marketplace [accomplished for the foreseeable future]; change the violent image of the game [concussions remain a massive issue]; curb salary inflation [perfect, except for the whole salary inflation part];…settle the divisive issue of possible Olympic involvement [“Bettman has not committed to altering the NHL season to accommodate for the Olympics”], and help launch several new expansion teams [more on this later].”

On February 1st, Bettman will celebrate his 20th year as commissioner. The league, which will almost certainly still be locked out, will not celebrate with him. The owners whose side he represents in the third labor-related work stoppage of his tenure may send him an Edible Arrangement or something. It won't be anything too splashy, though. Many of them weren't making much money before the lockout, and all of them currently spend what should be game nights—by their own choice, of course—staring at empty arenas.

***

I’m not an objective observer in the matter. I love hockey for what happens between the boards, and despise Bettman for—among other things—moving my beloved Hartford Whalers to Raleigh, North Carolina and changing their name to the Hurricanes. He did this with several other teams, including the Winnipeg Jets, Quebec Nordiques, and Minnesota North Stars. With only a few debatable cases, the southern migration has proved untenable. The NHL has been paying the city of Glendale some $25 million a year to keep the Coyotes; the Coyotes were formerly the Winnipeg Jets, who, it should be noted, got their team back last year when the Atlanta Thrashers—another of Bettman’s expansion teams—reinhabited Winnipeg. Both Florida teams are unprofitable, and the hockey teams in Columbus and Nashville are doing as well as you would think hockey teams in Columbus or Nashville would do. This is the market expansion Bettman was charged with accomplishing. He accomplished it, and it’s a spectacular clusterfuck.

For all the schadenfreude I derive from Bettman’s failures, I can’t fully condemn him for his role in the current lockout. I mean, I could, it's easy, but it doesn’t matter who is to blame anymore. What matters is that the central fallacy of Bettman's tenure is now quite clear. It's not so much that hockey was never meant for cities like Tampa Bay, Miami, Phoenix, Nashville or Columbus—although the numbers do tend to speak for themselves, there—so much as it is that hockey was perhaps never meant for a mass market in general.

Hockey deserves a large audience, certainly—one that consists of people who love hockey, as well as people who love people who love hockey and are willing to put up with them watching hockey and even make a token effort to pretend to care on occasion, and also for whatever misbegotten offspring issue from the relationship between the hockey-lover and the non-hockey lover. This is the hockey life-cycle. It is not one of aggressive expansion, but one of nurturing and quiet compromise, and one grounded in a peculiar sort of love. Under Gary Bettman, it has frequently been abandoned.

Despite being charged with ending labor unrest, Bettman has presided over three long lockouts: the season-shortening 1994-95 lockout, the season-ending 2004-05 lockout, and the current struggle. Some 2,223 hockey games (and counting) have been cancelled during Bettman’s divisive tenure. The NHL under Bettman is a league of instability—your team may move, your league may halt, your players may depart to skate on faraway ponds smoothed by strange Zambonis. This volatility, paradoxically enough, leads to even greater buy-in from the fans hearty enough to stick with the sport—we treasure every blessed instant of hockey, because since 1995, a lockout or a move or some other willed/dictated/preventable catastrophe has been fresh in everyone’s mind.

No other league deprives their fans of their product with such regularity in the name of making the game more popular. This is The Bettman Paradox: the league that shrinks in order to grow, the league that stops existing so it can continue to exist. And so the Winter Classic won’t be held this year, in front of an expected 110,000 hockey fans and bathed in the glow of universal media isn't-this-great delight, but it won't be held in the name of growing the fanbase. The season looks to be in serious jeopardy, but this is in order to showcase the product down the road. No gameday revenue will be collected, in the name of increasing profits. A more balanced division of revenues between owners and players is sought in hopes of leading to some blockbuster NHL hit down the line. Revenue sharing between the league's wildly and unsustainably unequal teams is… actually not being discussed, but there you go.

In the meantime, we are here. Hockey fans are not necessarily interested in what the league’s future possibilities are—it would be nice if it worked as a business, but as a sport it is already great, and beloved by many, all of whom love the sport and its dominant league for what they are, and have always been. Like his counterparts in the other major leagues, Bettman is an easy villain to target, but perhaps he has a larger, more ignoble-but-not-quite-villainous role to play in our sordid sport.

While Bettman and company will always seek their billion-dollar IMAX hit—some fluke-y Avatar that will pay for the next decade or so of misses—hockey fans have always been satisfied with the black-and-white, 16mm noir. In the beginning of Following, the writer starts shadowing random people in central London as a research method of sorts, and eventually befriends the thief in hopes of finding the great story that will bring him acclaim and success. Once they break into a few apartments together, he asks why the thief does what he does. The thief’s face sinks from congenially evil to purposeful: “You take it all away," he says, “to show them what they had.”

This is overdetermined, maybe, on Nolan's part. It is certainly something worse on Bettman's. But in the end, while Bettman may have taken 2,223 games from fans, he has belatedly made us appreciate what hockey is, and what it's worth. Hockey is, like all sports, something easily appreciated in the abstract, but much more fun in the present tense. For the moment, though, the former—all that abstraction, always and as ever—is all we've got.


Share |

Comments

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. bags & shoes

I truly inspired after read this on account of some quality work and instructive musings . I just wanna express profound gratitude for the author and want you to enjoy all that life has to offer for coming!. Wrap Him Around Your Finger

Your content is nothing short of brilliant in many ways. I think this is engaging and eye-opening material. Thank you so much for caring about your content and your readers. Spirulina Benefits

Hi there! Nice stuff, do keep me posted when you post again something like this! Relationship ebook

The data you have posted is extremely helpful. The locales you have alluded was great. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing.. Girl is horny

This web journal is truly awesome. The data here will definitely be of some help to me. Much appreciated!. Questions to ask

دانلود قسمت چهارم فصل دوم شهرزاد 2, دانلود رایگان شهرزاد, دانلود سریال جدید شهرزاد ایرانی دانلود سریال شهرزاد با لینک مستقیم, دانلود فیلم های جدید و برتر, دانلود رایگان فیلم و سریال با لینک مستقیم
دانلود قسمت چهارم شهرزاد دوم

Robert Downey Jr. collects art. Leonardo DiCaprio collects 22-year-old swimsuit models. Ashton Kutcher's hobby is acting like a Silicon Valley venture capitalist. loft conversions london

Robert Downey Jr. collects art. Leonardo DiCaprio collects 22-year-old swimsuit models. Ashton Kutcher's hobby is acting like a Silicon Valley venture capitalist. loft conversions london

Robert Downey Jr. collects art. Leonardo DiCaprio collects 22-year-old swimsuit models. Ashton Kutcher's hobby is acting like a Silicon Valley venture capitalist. loft conversions london

history involves a bunch of college kids in Lake Placid on tape delay. That first miracle has never been matched, and probably never will be.Study ny notary on line

Howdy! Decent stuff, do update me as often as possible when you post again something like this! italian menswear

This is also a very good post which I really enjoyed reading. It is not everyday that I have the possibility to see something like this.. cheap handbags for sale

bring him acclaim and success. Once they break into a few apartments together, he asks why the thief does what he does. The thief’s face sinks from congenially evil to purposeful: “You take it all away," he says, “to show them what they hadchess sets for schools

There are various types of arrangements that are accessible when you buy Instagram supporters. insta followers | insta likes

Like his counterparts in the other major leagues, Bettman is an easy villain to target, but perhaps he has a larger, more ignoble-but-not-quite-villainous role to play in our sordid sport.fast charging

I got your blog yesterday and still I am waiting for the new posts… this is quite satisfying blog so all guys come here and learn something special.
Facetime for Android

but in the NHL's belated rise into the ranks of the other outlandishly profitable professional sports leagues. Riding the Gretzky-in-Los Angeles wave, Gary Bettman was supposed to accomplish the following goals according agencia de marketing digital

going through a Golden Age of its own in the 80’s that took precedent. The defining moment in hockey's U.S. history involves a bunch of college kids in Lake Placid on tape delay. That first miracle has never been matched, and probably never will be.cancunplayas.com

Both Florida teams are unprofitable, and the hockey teams in Columbus and Nashville are doing as well as you would think hockey teams in Columbus or Nashville would do. This is the market expansion Bettman was charged with accomplishing. He accomplished it, and it’s a spectacular clusterfuck.forex rebates

history involves a bunch of college kids in Lake Placid on tape delay. That first miracle has never been matched, and probably never will be.faculdade mauricio nassau

if one that's a bit easier to relate to than its mega-sized and metastasized version. Which is what follows, invariably, if the smaller thing works, and grows.minecraft p e gratis |
free psn codes

Superbly written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a far better place.. escort paris

I absolutely feel ecstatic when I find articles relevant to my work and my subject. in-home care in shelton

Howdy! Pleasant post! It would be ideal if you let us know when I will see a postliminary! escorts in lebanon

This variety of official letterhead printing services is used primarily for administrative and service related purposes. affordable flyer printing online uk

You are very brave focuses in this article. I would have never thought to be any of these in the event that I didn't run over this. Much appreciated!. lebanon escort girls

nice bLog! its interesting. thank you for sharing.... t shirt printing canada

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. free credit score government

I want to say thanks for beautiful blog sharing with us. Your blog really great resource to update my knowledge. bohemians style

This is precisely what separates them from standard exercises. Oversized Clothing

Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. Definitely a great post.2009 odyssey car covers

Hello! This post couldn’t be written any better! Reading this post reminds me of my previous room mate! calculadora clausula suelo He always kept chatting about this. I will forward this page to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!.

Lyrapng's Fashion World

I would state, you do the genuinely amazing.This substance is made to a wonderful degree well.!
ALC Clothing

You need to desist getting inbound links from pages that jazz writer than 20 route or so. seo uk prices

Your article is extremely helpful exceptionally fascinating subject i am looking that sort of post thank for imparting to us keep it up. velociclos eléctricos

Thank you very much for this great post. I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that. Cleaner Brooklyn

Losing weight seems to be a health phenomenon nowadays as more and more people are engaging in this. Proper weight lose is essential and this include reliance on a natural and balanced form of diet combined with good exercise to the body. This article has highlighted the proper ways to lose weight and thanks for sharing this. home cleaning new york

Losing weight seems to be a health phenomenon nowadays as more and more people are engaging in this. Proper weight lose is essential and this include reliance on a natural and balanced form of diet combined with good exercise to the body. This article has highlighted the proper ways to lose weight and thanks for sharing this. home cleaning new york

This is a splendid web journal! I'm extremely content with the remarks!.. website

A debt of gratitude is in order for the post and awesome tips..even I additionally imagine that diligent work is the most imperative part of getting achievement.. tattoo supply

Hey buddies, such a marvelous blog you have made I’m surprised to read such informative stuff.
fashion

I got your blog yesterday and still I am waiting for the new posts… this is quite satisfying blog so all guys come here and learn something special.
fashion

This is the market expansion Bettman was charged with accomplishing. He accomplished it, and it’s a spectacular clusterfuck.car cover

I discovered your this post while hunting down some related data on site search...Its a decent post..keep posting and upgrade the data. werbeartikel günstig

How to get thousands of followers on instagram fast and free.instagram followers free instantly

Buy backlinks I was searching the blogs for a long time and that is good to know that I have found such blogs here. Great working! Keep it up! visit this site hurry !!! Dofollow Blog Comments

through a Golden Age of its own in the 80’s that took precedent. The defining moment in hockey's U.S. history involves a bunch of college kids in Lake Placid on tape delay. That first miracle has never been matched, and probably never will be.minecraft gratuit |
free psn codes

I was in such a deep sleep at the time! And it was cold outside! It made me so mad. Who was I hurting? I was next to a city park!nissan maxima car cover