What Does It Even Mean For A College Quarterback To Be Clutch?

Clutch, as a concept, is a slippery and subjective ideal under the best of circumstances. College football is not the best of circumstances. But there are still some answers to find, here, if we look.
Share |

In college football, maybe more than in any other sport, “clutch” is a slippery, dual-threat kind of word which ultimately jukes all those who try to define it. We think we know it when we see it, but thinking we see it is the bigger part of the problem—there are too many variables, too much bias, and, in college football, it is all balanced on college kids, some of the most profoundly irrational and volatile humans on earth. Of course, the same can be said of college football fans. We’re still going to look.

So let’s look. Probably the most obvious opposite of clutch is a subpar performance in the fourth quarter of a loss. Basing an assessment on this is usually unfair—again, any such hunt for clutch is likely to be—but a quarterback who fails to complete a few timely passes in crunch time or turns the ball over will inevitably wind up with the anti-clutch label. Through much of the first half of this college football season, Arkansas’ Brandon Allen has been a prime example.

By many metrics, the senior from Fayetteville is having a very solid season. Allen is completing 62% of his passes for 256 yards a game as Arkansas (2-4) enters a home game Saturday against Auburn (4-2) as a 5.5 point favorite. Allen ranks near the top of most SEC passing categories. Plus, he’s the fifth-best first-half Power 5 passer in the nation:


Name

School

Conference

 1st Half QB Rating

Treon Harris

Florida

SEC

237.22

Seth Russell

Baylor

Big 12

214.19

Trevone Boykin

TCU

Big 12

188.75

Cody Kessler

USC

Pac 12

182.31

Brandon Allen

Arkansas

SEC

179.84

But in close games, dating back more than two seasons now, Allen’s hot starts have tended to come with cold finishes. In 2013, his QB rating dropped about 50 points on average from the first half to the fourth quarter. Last year it was at that level again—the worst drop off in the nation:


Name

Team

Conf.

1st Half Rating

3rd Qter Rating

4th Qter Rating

OT Rating

Diff b/t 3rd & 4th qters

Diff b/t 1st Half & 4th qter

Brandon Allen

Arkansas

SEC

137.96

151.91

86.56

167.2

-65.35

-51.4

Brad Kaaya

Miami (Fl)

ACC

158.64

152.71

107.36

0

-45.35

-51.28

Chad Voytik

Pittsburgh

ACC

152.16

143.04

112.61

0

-30.43

-39.55

Travis Wilson

Utah

Pac 12

138.85

140.44

99.52

217.31

-40.92

-39.33

Kevin Hogan

Stanford

Pac 12

158.47

125.8

119.86

213.07

-5.94

-38.61

Allen’s inefficiency down the stretch has impacted his teammates, and visa versa. The offense on the whole was top 10 per the advanced statistics-driven first-half punch, but staggered in at 82nd in fourth-quarter production. You will likely not be surprised to learn Arkansas lost all four of its close games in 2014. Still, the team finished strong and the good vibes were supposed to carry over into this season. For the most part, they have not.

Arkansas recently lost three games in a row, and on October 10 was stifled by Alabama in a 27-14 loss. The reshuffled offensive line was slow to click, and injuries to the team’s all-SEC running back and top wide receivers haven’t helped. In losses against Toledo, Texas Tech and Texas A&M, the Hogs regularly stymied their own offensive momentum with ill-timed penalties in the second half. The defense has tightened in recent games but its backfield breakdowns led to back-breaking long touchdowns passes in the second half of Texas A&M and Alabama. The struggles have been a team effort.

Still, at the end of each of this year’s four losses, Allen missed important throws. In a win against Tennessee, his solid work as a game manager down the stretch seemed to owe more to the offensive line and running backs for pounding out the clock. “I’m shocked that Brandon's having a difficult year getting the ball to the people that are open when they're open,” Fox Sports’ Tim Brando told Sports Talk with Bo Mattingly a few weeks ago. “He's still late getting the passes to the receivers when they need to be there. I thought he would be ahead of schedule.”

He’s not, and until two weeks ago the fifth-year senior was again worst in the nation among starting quarterbacks in terms of first half-to-fourth quarter rating dropoff. Since then, a subpar first half against Alabama helped narrow the gap so that Allen now ranks No. 7 in this category:


Name

School

Conference

1st Half QB Rating

3rd Qter Rating

4th qter Rating

Overtime Rating

Diff b/t 3rd & 4th qters

Diff b/t 1st Half and 4th quarter

Treon Harris

Florida

SEC

237.22

106.55

122.31

0

-15.76

-114.91

John Wolford

Wk Forest

ACC

146.45

152.98

64.02

0

88.96

-82.43

Jared Goff

California

Pac 12

165.55

207.38

85.52

0

121.86

-80.03

Jacoby Brissett

NC State

ACC

172.5

122.54

94.16

0

28.38

-78.34

Cody Kessler

USC

Pac 12

182.31

184.9

112.84

0

72.06

-69.47

Sam Richardson

Iowa State

Big 12

151.67

155.48

82.94

41.8

72.54

-68.73

Brandon Allen

Arkansas

SEC

179.84

129.58

111.32

47.33

18.26

-68.52

This is where narratives come from, but if the perception of Allen’s issues at the end of games isn’t totally unfair, it also lacks context.

Allen, for instance, hardly attempted a pass in the fourth quarter in a 28-21 overtime loss to Texas A&M as the coaches called mostly running plays. The pieces around Allen haven’t been consistent either. If TE Hunter Henry not been called a holding penalty at the one-yard line in the fourth quarter against Toledo, Arkansas would have likely scored a touchdown and won. Just like that, Arkansas would now be 3-3, with hopes of a prestige bowl still intact and far fewer fans would be questioning Allen’s clutch bona fides. If a team wins, a starting quarterback’s shaky end-game performances seem to matter that much less.

Context is also vital when looking at the college football quarterbacks who would be King of Clutch. On the surface, Arizona’s Anu Solomon appears God-like in the fourth quarter, where this season he’s led his team to five wins and has racked up an obscenely good 336.6 rating, a full 114 points better than runner-up Trevone Boykin of TCU. Yet a concussion also happened to knock Solomon out of the fourth quarter of Arizona’s two hardest games so far in blowout losses to UCLA and Stanford. Until Solomon’s stats incorporate performances against significantly more Power 5 defenses than Colorado’s and Oregon State’s, any coronation should be delayed.

“Clutch” may be largely undefinable, but that hasn’t stopped ESPN from trying to will it into their proprietary Total Quarterback Rating statistics secret sauce. That stat is predictably imperfect but better than the sclerotic QB Rating - which has its origins in the late 1960s - in gauging quarterback performance, and how that performance affects winning. Total QBR takes into account factors like rushing yards, fumbles, and whether a dropped pass is a wide receiver’s fault or not.

It also includes a “clutch” factor which takes into account field position and how close the game appears to be a specific point in time. “Down four points with three seconds to go and facing third-and-goal from the 3-yard line—that is a high-pressure and high-clutch index situation because the play can realistically raise the odds of winning to almost 100 percent or bring them down from about 40 percent to almost zero percent,” advanced stats sensei Dean Oliver wrote.

The NFL quarterbacks who consistently perform better in these kinds of circumstances are the ones we know as “winners.” Joe Montana and John Elway and Aaron Rodgers—whom Miami quarterback Brad Kaaya considers “the definition of clutch”—become perceived as crunch-time performers who elevate their play at the end of games, in part because they actually do this and in part because of all the other complicated and selective reasons that such players wind up with this sort of rep.

The QBR and its clutch metrics are less helpful in grading college quarterbacks than their pro counterparts. For one, data is drawn from a significantly larger sample size, as NFL seasons are longer and because most starting college quarterbacks don’t play heavy minutes for more than three seasons. More important, though, is the fact NFL teams play on a more level field in terms of talent. Every team in the NFL has a raft of talented players, and every NFL quarterback throws to NFL-grade receivers.

This is not so in college, where the talent levels of teams can wildly fluctuate along conference and divisional lines. This makes apple to apple comparisons of certain “clutch” attributes more difficult. Braxton Miller led the nation in game-winning touchdown drives heading into 2014, which is impressive. But he also had the benefit of playing alongside plenty of blue-chip teammates, and against defenses that were on balance weaker than SEC teams’ in that three-year period. Everything, for better or worse, is more variable in college football.

An individualized “strength of schedule”-type metric that adds fuller context to these quarterback ratings doesn’t exist yet. Creating it, and then adding it to an improved QB rating, would be a good starting point on the topic of how college quarterbacks finish. Until then, we’ll keep on having the same old arguments. Afterwards, too.


Share |

Comments

I got so involved in this material that I couldn’t stop reading. I am impressed with your work and skill. Thank you so much.
Loans in Nigeria

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore, I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
Zahnklinik Bern

RepuNEXT gives one-stop for all Business needs and Advisory services and takes your Reputation to the next level.chennai based web design company

I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post.
writing

I appreciate everything you have added to my knowledge base.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks.
stream TV

Great job for publishing such a beneficial web site. Your web log isn’t only useful but it is additionally really creative too. There tend to be not many people who can certainly write not so simple posts that artistically. Continue the nice writing
Aquarium

This is such a great resource that you are providing and you give it away for free. I love seeing blog that understand the value of providing a quality resource for free.
BUY WEBSITE TRAFFIC

I propose merely very good along with reputable data, consequently visualize it:
twosome

This content is simply exciting and creative. I have been deciding on a institutional move and this has helped me with one aspect.
Best alternatives to XTB

Hmm… I interpret blogs on a analogous issue, however i never visited your blog. I added it to populars also i’ll be your faithful primer.
XTB alternatives

I came onto your blog while focusing just slightly submits. Nice strategy for next, I will be bookmarking at once seize your complete rises...
small artificial christmas tree

I can give you the address Here you will learn how to do it correctly. Read and write something good.
artificial trees

Can't get over the way that words can be utilized this flawlessly.
USB data recovery on Mac

I like this post,And I guess that they having fun to read this post,they shall take a good site to make a information,thanks for sharing it to me.
serwery minecraft

Thank you so much Love your blog..
https://www.povd.com

Me and my companions have completely delighted in this blog.
bffs

Not a solitary second abandoned abandoning me in absolute shock.
Chiropractor

Pleasantly surprised to see this meshwork of amazing words.
먹튀

Such a great blog and all the writings. Can’t help thinking about the author.
ambulance deep cleaning

I think this is a really good article. You make this information interesting and engaging. You give readers a lot to think about and I appreciate that kind of writing.
security camera installation miami fl

A gigantic yell out to the essayist who emptied his spirit into this blog.
latest fashion for men

Some things are good. Some are great. Then comes this blog.
buena park plumber

A sumptuous blog, honestly. Valued each and every piece of it.
Mcdvoice

A blog that mushroomed from visual enlightenment.
http://lib.exdat.com/docs/1636/index-19392.html

Can hardly wait for another blog by this essayist.
Member XXL Review

This blog is so valuable. A present for the blog perusers.
blacklattereviews.com

How delightfully every one of the sentiments have been passed on through composing.
detoxicofficialsite.com

Interesting and amazing how your post is! It Is Useful and helpful for me That I like it very much, and I am looking forward to Hearing from your next..
daftar judi sbobet

a

I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it. I have you bookmarked your site to check out the new stuff you post.
Situs Panduan Bola Terupdate

Anti-wrinkle face creams counter and prevent the development of wrinkles, boost collagen production for enhanced skin elasticity and firmness and protect your skin from the harmful effects of UV rays and environmental pollutants. While most anti-wrinkles creams reduce skin problems, you can choose one depending on your specific needs and requirements, and skin type.dig this - does booty pop really work

Amazingly composed blog that has transfixed its crowd.
تعلم الانجليزية للمبتدئين

Impressive work on the writer’s part.
https://www.familystrokes.com

Inspiring and very useful, highly recommended for all bloggers out there.
familystrokes

The more I read, the more I fell deep into it.
molds for ceramic bisque

Been searching for such an astonishing web diary like this for a long time.
glazed ceramic art

In the wake of perusing such astonishing works, your heart gets empowered.
click here

Very good points you wrote here..Great stuff...I think you've made some truly interesting points.Keep up the good work.
odzyskiwanie danych Warszawa

This is my first time i visit here and I found so many interesting stuff in your blog especially it's discussion, thank you.
odzyskiwanie danych Warszawa

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work
eT20slam

I surely acquiring more difficulties from each surprisingly more little bit of it
dhankesari lottery result

Can't get over the way that words can be utilized this flawlessly.
카지노사이트

Saw many blogs. Read many writings. This is something different. Something amazing.
odzyskiwanie danych Poznań

This blog is a first class work, It is indeed a classic work of art.
POVD

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
https://www.tipandroid.com/

This is an astonishing website second to none.
agen kiu online

I’m happy I located this blog! From time to time, students want to cognitive the keys of productive literary essays composing. Your first-class knowledge about this good post can become a proper basis for such people. nice one
Muslim chat room

I surely acquiring more difficulties from each surprisingly more little bit of it
best vacuum for long hair uk

This post is very simple to read and appreciate without leaving any details out. Great work!
poker online bri

this is really nice to read..informative post is very good to read..thanks a lot!
best vacuum for apartment