The Lunardi Problem

There's nothing wrong with some NCAA Tournament speculation. But a little Bracketology goes a very long way.
Share |

In the delightful Liz-Lemon-gets-married episode of 30 Rock, a secondary storyline centered upon Jack Donaghy's realization that he’s half the man he used to be. He confesses to Jenna that he is no longer a Master of the Universe; he, a man who could count among his many accomplishments, “coin[ing] the phrase, ‘You Wish, Pal’” in the 1980s. Later, Donaghy stares forlornly at a gold plaque on his wall commemorating his linguistic feat. 

It was a classic 30 Rock throwaway, but good enough to roll around in my head for days after. “You Wish, Pal” is such a perfectly banal bit o’snark that it sounds universal, although it never achieved anything near critical rhetorical mass. As far as “meaningless phraseology that becomes ubiquitous and pointlessly enters the national dialogue,” does that phrase have anything on “You Go Girl,” “Don’t Go There,” or—most vexingly and of the moment—“Bracketology?” You wish.

***

Marquette’s first Big East road game of this season came at Pitt. It was a big game for Marquette fans (I'm one) and Pitt fans and a certain type of masochistic gambler and Big East completist, but otherwise it was not. Otherwise it was just another middling early-season contest on a college basketball calendar filled with them. The announcing team of Beth Mowins and Tim Welsh were ideal for a January tilt on ESPNU—blandly competent, but mercifully free of schtick, gimmickry and canned anecdotes. They were fine, until college basketball's resident defective oracle showed up.

“Guess who’s in the house?" Mowins crowed at one break in the action. "Our Bracketologist, Joe Lunardi. He’s everywhere!”

And the St. Joseph's administrator and ESPN's resident NCAA Tournament seer really is everywhere, especially at this time of year. In this case, it was more precise to say that Joe Lunardi was in the Petersen Events Center, in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, at noon, on Saturday January 12, 2013, for a basketball game being aired on a secondary network owned by the large sports media corporation that pays him to be the resident Bracketologist. He was maybe there for his own pleasure. It was maybe a coincidence. But the minute ESPNU's broadcasters mentioned his name, it was clear. It was clear that Lunardi was going to fart all over the broadcast, stankin’ and speculatin' on the airwaves at the expense of the actual game being played on the court.

And it came to pass, and we got—as the game went on—such (admittedly paraphrased) Lunardi-an analyses such as:

“It’s never too early to talk about number-one seeds.” (Yes, it is.)

And, “Obviously, you’ve got the top two, both unbeaten, Duke and Michigan...” (Both would lose within 26 hours)

This was annoying, but mostly for how familiar it is. When last Lundardi's ebullient, grinning shadow darkened a Marquette game, late last season, it was the same intra-office knob-polishing ensued.

“Year-in, year-out, you want to know who is going to the Big Dance, you go to ESPN.com and see who Joe Lunardi’s picked." (And then a beat for frantic mirth, or some basketball) “He has a Ph.D. in Bracketology!” (And another) “How does he do it!” (And some fist-bumps, presumably.)

We could all, now, take a deep breath, and for one moment, pause to recognize that Bracketology isn’t actually a thing. It’s just a parlor game, fun for spitballing at the sports bar, but not a field of actual study. There are not degrees awarded; it's not like someone can take a class in the study of Bracketology, right? Oh.

I stand corrected. 

This, too, is Joe Lunardi's fault.

***

It was St. Thomas Aquinas who said, “Wonder is the Desire of Knowledge...But when in doubt default to KenPom.

The thirst for a deeper understanding of the human condition, as represented in a $5 office pool, must be why the fine Jesuit community at St. Joseph’s University offers an online certification in the “Fundamentals of Bracketology,” which concerns the "art and science" (the art!) of forecasting which teams will be selected for a given year's NCAA men's basketball championship. The professor, naturally, is Joe Lunardi, who is also the school's vice president for marketing communications. He oversees institutional marketing and branding, program advertising, web content, and other integrated communications initiatives. He correctly forecast all 65 teams for the 2008 NCAA Tournament and has averaged no more than one missed team for the past eight seasons. You can call him "Joey Brackets." And for the fully reasonable price of $99, he will give students a firm understanding of the principles of "Bracketology" as applied to Division I college basketball and the NCAA® men's basketball championship and includes a history of the NCAA Tournament ("March Madness®").

There will be: course study of the team selection and seeding process, and the analysis undertaken by individual schools/conferences to position themselves for NCAA championship participation. The course will also explore the most common misconceptions "behind the bracket" as portrayed by the print/electronic media. Common misconceptions like say calling Rutgers and Villanova “bubble teams,” after two weeks of Big East conference play? Something along those lines?

The good news is that there won't be much in the way of math—the mathematical forecasting thing (and the giving away such information for free thing) is for your Ken Pomeroys and Ratings Percentage Index. This is not that. Here, there is the sort of erudition that can only be gathered at courtside of a random Marquette/Pitt game. Here there is a final exam in which students complete a mock bracket, and participate in a mock selection committee meeting, moderated by Joe, and construct their own NCAA Men's Basketball Tournament bracket. Sure, there will be a lot of studying. Maybe some all-nighters. But when it's over, hoops scholars will earn a Certificate of Completion from Saint Joseph's University and a copy of the final bracket signed by Joe himself. Seating is limited.

***

Okay, so ESPN's resident bracketologist makes my skin crawl. Why? Is it charging $100 for a master class in his signature mix of “art and science,” which could probably be more accurately described as a combination of “watch college basketball” and “educated guesswork?” Actually, that doesn’t bother me. If someone wants to pony up a C-note for eight-weeks of nonsense, that’s their business. This is America, man. For a mere $49.99, your author—some call him “Paddy Buckets”—will personally call you, on your own phone, with his personal NCAA Tourney bracket based on his patented “catch parts of some games and then look some shit up on the internet” methodology. Let the market decide.

Does it bug me that Lunardi makes a big fuss about his success rate picking the teams that get into the NCAA tournament, even though it’s not that hard? There are 31 automatic bids, easily another 30 that can be plucked from the various rankings, another 30 that enjoy overwhelming odds of getting in, and maybe three or four remaining wild cards. In essence, Joey Buckets is spotted 64 teams with four slots to fill. In 2012, he missed onein 2011 he missed three, but in 2008, as we’ve been told, he nailed the entire field. It's up to you what the statute of forcastication is and whether access to it is worth your hard-earned dollars. 

As for the simulacrum of Lunardi’s seeding expertise...well, there's that. But once St. Patrick’s Day—doubling as Selection Sunday this year, in what may be a hazardous development for America's livers—rolls around, nobody cares. Noooooo. Bodddddddy. Selection Sunday is fantastic because there is so much to talk about—Final Four predictions, toughest region, best first-round match-ups, upset specials, pool-filling strategies, biggest snubs, MOP potential, foxiest cheerleaders and illest mascots, and so on.

Not on this long list: the accuracy with which Joe Lunardi, or any other Bracketologist, forecasted tournament seeding. Actual seedings will matter—fans will complain, sometimes they will be right—but theoretical seedings not at all. It would be like if kids on Christmas morning sat around ignoring their toys and discussing which presents had been wrapped most efficiently.

“No, we do not offer wagers on where teams will be seeded in the NCAA Tourney," Scott Ghertner of MGM Resorts International told me. "[And I] don’t imagine other non-MGM Resorts Sportsbooks do either.” In terms of potential return-on-investment, students holding a Joey Brackets diploma might as well have a classics degree. Once the tournament starts, of course, Lunardi himself is on his way back to obscurity, and his high-volume inanities, however accurate they were or weren't, are something to take out with the recycling the next day.

***

There's nothing wrong with Lunardi's gimmickry, given the right context and timing. Two weeks into conference play, it's easy to ignore Bracketology in favor of just watching the season unfold. Late in the season, with various possibilities now mostly unfolded, I'll check on Lunardi—along with all the other prognosticators, like this one here, or here, or here, or over here—to see where they have Marquette (and everyone else) pegged. This wasting of time on hypotheticals is on me; dropping thick slices of phony-bologna Lunardi-an speculation into actual game broadcasts is on ESPN though. And it's silly.

Of course, of course most sports fans would love to quit ESPN, but it’s damn near impossible when it comes to college basketball. ESPN is where the games are. When Monday Night Football invited mooks like Sylvester Stallone and Jim Belushi into the booth some years ago—when they gave Dennis Miller a job talking about football on live television—these were clumsy plays for non-football viewers. Fans bitched and the experiment went by the wayside. Lunardi and his signature pseudoscience, though, are considered to add some value to the game-watching process. He's as permanent as he is fatuous.

Lunardi, in the goofy pseudo-field he invented, is an expert—a Ph.D., as we’re reminded every time he enlightens us with insights about VCU being a “virtual lock on my board” while the Rams attempt to go 2-0 in conference play. This is the kind of banter that fills the hours at ESPN, the kind that has zero to do with what the teams he was bigfooting were doing right in front of him. As terrible as much of ESPN's programming is, it's also easy to avoid—I skip Skip, I don't want a First Take, I avoid Greenie and Gunt in the Morning, I have no take on Tebow or The Decision. But, through Lunardi, all that unwanted and under-reasoned conjecture invades what's supposed to be a safe space from it. At least when Jim Belushi shows up in the booth, you know that he's a clown. Lunardi, goofy though he is, is given some casual respectability, treated as a folksy oracle (with a Ph.D.!). He’s worse than Glenn Beck, he’s David Brooks. Please do not get David Brooks in my basketball.

***

Saturday evening found Marquette on ESPN 2 doing battle with Villanova at the Pavilion, Villanova's smaller, louder on-campus arena. It was a mildly important game for Marquette to stay tied atop the Big East, but it was huge for Villanova because they were “one of the last four out” of the NCAA tournament as the game tipped. There was an on-screen graphic of this stone cold fact. The second time it appeared, Mike Patrick had the decency to add, "according to our resident Bracketologist Joe Lunardi." The game was being played in Philadelphia, which is Lunardi's hometown and… and, oh no. No, not again.

"This is the most important 15 minutes of Villanova’s season," Lunardi told Patrick and color commentator Len Elmore, when they invited him to join them on air. "Until the next game."

“We didn’t use to update these things every half hour,” Lunardi says to general guffaws. But hey, since we do, the two spent an entire segment talking about Miami’s beatdown by Wake Forest; Marquette/Villanova, which was the game all three were attending, was at that point a one-point game.

After a dubious charge call, Patrick interrupted the conversation to point out that there have been a number of them and they’ve all gone to the defense. Important, relevant, curious, and so a natural segue for Patrick to return to what didn't matter. "Speaking of bad losses"—nobody was—"Let’s get back to Miami and Wake Forest."

And the topline prattling continued, broken up briefly by a hard Marquette foul that pushed momentum Villanova’s way. Elmore asked Lunardi’s theoretical take on the Duke/Miami game, which would air on ESPN. In a week’s time.

Then Patrick, for reasons unknown, asked for Lunardi’s thoughts on the Fighting Illini's chances. Did Lunardi say, “If they collect one more scalp...” Yep. Did he say, “Well, this is Bracket Busters weekend...” Yes he did, although no it’s not, and that’s a made up alliteration anyhow. Did he say that if he were “doing it”—officially seeding teams, which he’s not—standbys like Kentucky and Kansas would get a second look because of the “human element.” I think you know the answer.

Mercifully, a commercial break ended Lunardi’s time. But not before Elmore chimed in with “P.H.D...Bracketology...My Doc-tah.”

***

I am maybe too upset by all this. This is maybe Mountains Out of Joehills. Fair enough, but here’s the kicker: Lunardi, resident Bracketologist, isn’t any fucking good at his job. 

To amend an earlier statement—there actually is a small group that cares about the accuracy of Lunardi’s predictions. These are your non-televised bracketologists, for whom this sort of prognostication is a hobby. According to The Bracket Project, a website that “measures how closely each Bracketologist got to matching the work of the selection committee,” but doesn’t have anything “to do with who is the best at picking winners in the NCAA tournament,” Lunardi is an average student at best, certainly not a postdoctorate by any means.

The Bracket Project has two rankings of its “final exam grades." The more thorough one is for prognosticators that have participated for at least three years. Joe Lunardi comes in 36th out of 65. That's barely above the mean, right behind Schmolik 64 and two slots ahead of Bluejay Banter Bracketology. It's unlikely that either of those predictors could get $100 for a course in their methodology and an autographed bracket, but neither deserves it any less than Lunardi.

This won't change anything, of course. Lunardi has been branded thicker than an Omega Psi Phi pledge, and the doomsday hype machine in Bristol doesn't have an off switch. He's just another network personality to deal with, and he's free to leverage that notoriety however he wishes. But does this mean we need to give credence to—or pay attention to, or not actively, grumblingly mute—Lunardi when he bum-rushes the mic and starts spitting oracular pronouncements? You Wish, Pal. 


Share |

Comments

what is chapter 13 bankruptcy
Your blogs further more each else volume is so entertaining further serviceable It appoints me befall retreat encore. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.

I am glad to discover this post Very valuable for me, as it contains part of data. I Always like to peruse The Quality and happy I discovered this thing in you post. Alkaline Diet food List

Christmas morning sat around ignoring their toys and discussing which presents had been wrapped most efficiently.ถุงซิปล็อค

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.
wordpress chat room plugin

Amazing, this is truly fascinating perusing. I am happy I discovered this and got the opportunity to peruse it. Awesome employment on this substance. I like it. here

I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!
https://miappy.com/royale-revolt-2-hack/

a debt of gratitude is in order for this usefull article, sitting tight for this article like this once more. feliz en vista q2

Just try to specify ones substance can be as unimaginable. This clarity with your post is heavenly and that i may believe you're a master for this issue. High caliber alongside your agree license me to grab your present provide for keep adjusted by utilizing drawing closer blog entry. Much appreciated many alongside you ought to go on the pleasurable take care of business. lords mobile hack

hampton bay patio furniture
I’m happy I located this blog! From time to time, students want to cognitive the keys of productive literary essays composing. Your first-class knowledge about this good post can become a proper basis for such people.

I continuously livelihood on upcoming to your parcel again retributory in containerful you have posted new list. Essay grader

I was surfing net and luckily ran over this site and discovered extremely fascinating stuff here. Its truly amusing to peruse. I delighted in a ton. A debt of gratitude is in order for sharing this magnificent data. Do follow back link service | Buy low obl backlinks

Head on around to our estimating site to collect your first advertising effort. auto liker We are one in everything about number of associations that guarantee our system which will deliver durable, auto liker fruitful results in your fan site page.

We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.
chapter 13 bankruptcy definition

If it's not too much trouble proceed with this incredible work and I anticipate a greater amount of your wonderful blog entries. girlsdoporn

This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article. beste Online-Casino

borum escort bayan
Incredible posting this is from you. I am really and truly thrilled to read this marvelous post. You've really impressed me today. I hope you'll continue to do so!

I continuously livelihood on upcoming to your parcel again retributory in containerful you have posted new list. gaming tastatur

I will be possessed with more near topics. Genuinely propelled ! Everything is particularly open and clear brightening of issues. casino sbobet

Great article, much obliged for assembling this! This is clearly one extraordinary post. A debt of gratitude is in order for the important data and bits of knowledge you have so given here buy facebook likes cheap

I am overwhelmed by your post with such a nice topic. Usually I visit your blogs and get updated through the information you include but today’s blog would be the most appreciable
have a peek at this website

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
click for more information

That publish offers served everyone for an post that we 'm writing. Appreciate it intended for giving everyone another point of view for this subject. Currently I am able to effortlessly full our post
​طراحی پلاگین وردپرس

Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. Strong Article

I truly value this superb post that you have accommodated us. I guarantee this would be helpful for a large portion of the general population. how to make quick money online

I really appreciate this wonderful post that you have provided for us. I assure this would be beneficial for most of the people. home interiors

I feel really finicky reading these articles I mean there are writers that can write reasonable stuff.
30 year fixed rate life insurance

This article is actually remarkable one it helps many new users that desire to read always the best stuff.
Shailandra Singh Sequoia Capital

I enjoy what you guys are up too Usually. This sort of clever work and coverage! Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve added you guys to my blogroll
portfolio

Many thanks for the exciting blog posting! Simply put your blog post to my favorite blog list and will look forward for additional updates. Simply wanted to write down a word in order to say thanks to you for those wonderful tips.
furniture style

Thumbs up guys your doing a really good job. Standmixer

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.  discoteche della versilia

Spot on with this write-up, I really feel this website needs a great deal more attention. I’ll probably be returning to read more, thanks for the info! سئو

It offers you elegant and practical antique mirrored sideboard that features hardwood frame, granite top and bevelved mirror veneers. It has 3 drawers, 2 doors and 2 shelves with golden finish on frame. This one-off furniture piece is perfect for your dining and living room. home design

doing my essay
I discovered your site ideal for me. It consists of wonderful and useful posts. I've read many of them and also got so much from them. In my experience, you do the truly amazing.Truly i'm impressed out of this publish

Fitness experts recommend the following for a long time, and frequently can not help in cases of non-effective plans. Some people also plan to pursue unethical, even through surgery to get some extra body excess fat and have some decent appearance fat diminisher system reviews

Many people are waiting for the Fresh Year to start. We certainly have many of the planning's for our life in this year. People established new goals to attain success in this forthcoming year. It is the best time to organise parties and go for getting together with your entire around and dear ones. We are also trying our level best to give wonderful gifts to all our valuable clients. We all are constantly making efforts to deliver the best service to our visitors. Happy New year 2017 Images

I enjoy what you guys are up too Usually. This sort of clever work and coverage! Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve added you guys to my blogroll
time zone database

Everyone in France is not accredited to offer a loan and credit to individuals remains a supervised activity. If an individual or group promotes online financial services, the website is obliged to publish its legal information and general conditions.  Attention aux arnaques sur les réseaux sociaux

This is really very nice post you shared, i like the post, thanks for sharing..
departamentos en renta cancun

There are hundreds, maybe thousands, of people who review books for publication in magazines and newspapers, many more who review books on the Web. If you add in those who review magazines, newspapers, movies, theater, blogs, websites, Face book styles, Twitter tweets, what have you, buy custom book report

It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.
student card

I’m happy I located this blog! From time to time, students want to cognitive the keys of productive literary essays composing. Your first-class knowledge about this good post can become a proper basis for such people.
UMB Writing Services

Interesting and amazing how your post is! It Is Useful and helpful for me That I like it very much, and I am looking forward to Hearing from your next..
hackinguniversity

There will be 3 papers for group 2 services and the examination will be conducted in single, mode. The detailed syllabus each paper will be given below. appsc group 2 syllabus download

This is cool post and i enjoy to read this post. your blog is fantastic and you have good staff in your blog. nice sharing keep it up.
اختبار تحصيلي

Dos4s liker is the best Facebook auto like website, which not only gives free Auto Liker on your statuses, photos, videos or on custom posts Fb Auto followers Page Auto Liker, but also provides privacy and security as Dos4s is 100% safe auto liker, and we don't post anything on your behalf on any wall, group or page.Auto Liker

Top Mejores Informaciones sobre la Viagra y sobre como comprar Viagra . ¿Qué es el Viagra? 10 razones sorbe lo que debe saber acerca de Viagra, 4 efectos positivos y 5 secundarios que todo el mundo debe saber s usa la Viagra. Las mejores maneras sobre cómo comprar Viagra en España y en todo el mundo en el año 2016. comprar viagra

It was very useful for me. I'm happy I found this blog. Thank you for sharing with us,I too always learn something new from your post.Visit our website at obat tumor In Home Blood Test Montreal

I wish to show thanks to you just for bailing me out of this particular trouble.As a result of checking through the the net and meeting techniques that were not productive, I was thinking my life was done.
mattress online

It is the intent to provide valuable information and best practices, including an understanding of the regulatory process. new year 2017 images