Evolution and Extinction in New Orleans

In half-loving memory of the New Orleans Saints' defense, the NFL's fattest remora.
Share |
Smashy smashy...38-35.

Illustration by Jason Torchinsky.

To say that it has been hard to be a New Orleans Saints fan in recent years would be unfair. It would be churlish. Grotesque. It would also be hugely out of context: it has been easier to be a Saints fan lately than at any other time in history. So, yes: all of that. But, though we didn’t necessarily know it at the time, the NFL lost one of its most compulsively watchable pieces of weirdness when the 49ers knocked the Saints out of the playoffs. Not the Drew Brees-powered offense, although that carnival left town, too, when Alex Smith decided not to be Alex Smith for a still-implausible 5 minutes. No, the weirdness was on the other side of the ball, where defensive coordinator Gregg Williams continued to define defense down in ever stranger and less effective ways.

With the departure of Williams to St. Louis, the violent, anarchic free-for-all that New Orleans was forced to call “a defense” will not be seen again anytime soon, at least unless the Rams visit the Superdome. This is fine, of course, if also a little sad. Usually, the sui generis label is applied to something unique and extraordinary. Pathbreaking and riveting. The Saints defense during the Williams years was none of these things, but it was also sui generis. How does a defense like this develop? The answer won’t be found by analyzing game tape; to understand the Gregg Williams Ineffective Mayhem Experiment, we must turn to evolutionary biology.

But first, for those who never had the dubious pleasure of regularly watching the GWIME, a pop culture analogy is probably in order. The 2009 Saints defense was what early Friday Night Lights would have been if Saracen were a Zach Thomas-ian linebacker, Smash a cornerback in the Deion Sanders mold and Riggins was smoldering and sulky but played defense. That is, they blundered with what was either self-defeating generosity or abject indifference into desperate and melodramatic straits, then triumphed telegenically at the last possible moment. More often than not, this happened when opponents returned the here-have-all-this-yardage favor by throwing the ball into the arms of an end-stage Darren Sharper, who by that point could no longer cover anyone, but was cagey enough to put himself in the path of bad passes. The 2010 defense, in contrast, looked good to the computers, although the humiliation they suffered at the stiff arms and churning feet of Seattle's Marshawn Lynch in the Beast Mode wild card game was what the defense looked like all season to my eyes. This year, both computers and my eyes agreed that the Saints defense was a catastrophe. Infuriating as the unit was to watch, it was at least refreshing to have my paranoia justified.

In all those seasons, the Saints defense was grounded in a simple philosophy: blitz a lot, from all angles; pressure the quarterback constantly; and just let the rest happen. It is, as described, a compelling idea. It was, as executed, terrible. Nothing stands out statistically about these defenses—although, after the unit’s aberrant billion-pick season in 2009, the Saints more or less stopped intercepting passes—but they were distinguished, in my memory and on game tape, as a truly terrible tackling team. (The sole exception is safety Roman Harper, who can’t cover a statue, but at least hits hard enough to knock one over.) Still, the team won much more than it lost, and there was never so much as a whisper that Williams’ job was in trouble.

On reflection, Williams was never in jeopardy because to see the Saints defense as simply “bad” is to fail to put it in its context. The GWIME developed in tandem with the Drew Brees High Octane Touchdown Fantasia, and came to fill a weird evolutionary niche alongside that offense. It was, in retrospect, a very comfortable niche. The Saints defense didn’t have to make the play on every down, or most downs. It didn’t have to stop the opposing offense from scoring on every drive, or most drives. If Williams threw the kitchen sink at the quarterback often enough, eventually the quarterback would respond with two incomplete passes in a row. The GWIME needed only to succeed more than the opposing team's defense did against DBHOTF, and even great defenses don’t stop the DBHOTF much.

Whether or not this worked, it did at least seem like everyone was having fun. The defense is happy because they get to throw their bodies around with abandon, hitting everyone and everything as hard as they can, picking up the odd personal foul (one per game, at least), stopping the opposing team from scoring on occasion and generally enjoying the pleasantness of a pressure-free job. Brett Favre is probably still icing down his sore legs from the 2009 NFC Championship game; he also threw for 300 yards. Even the Saints offense is happy, in this situation, because after scoring a touchdown they can relax and really enjoy their Gatorade—savor the electrolytes without rushing or gulping—while the defense gives up a long drive and a field goal.

Even the season-ending divisional round loss to the 49ers doesn’t confound the theory. Sure, it was awful that the defense gave up two late touchdowns, but that’s how the defense works. It looked buggy to the uninitiated because it was Alex Smith tear-assing downfield instead of a better-branded chucker, but this was the GWIME that almost let Jake Locker two-minute drill them. Ultimately, breakdowns on offense lost the Saints this game. Of the five Saints turnovers, four forced a bad defense to defend a short field. The defense, unsurprisingly, yielded 13 points on those drives. But, more importantly, those turnovers killed four drives for the DBHOTF, a sacrifice of roughly 17 points (this is an estimate that certainly feels accurate). The fifth turnover, a concussion-induced Pierre Thomas fumble on the three-yard line, cost New Orleans three more, and the game.

Essentially, the Saints defense rides, remora-like, on the shark that is the offense. It hangs around and provides some ambiguous benefit—Gatorade savoring, breath-catching, so on—to the shark while doing no real harm, and living large on the excreta of the killing machine to which it is attached. This defense, more than most, simply can’t survive 33-point negative delta from the offense. A remora can only eat so much shark shit.

Evolutionary biologists say that the eye evolved separately dozens of times; we may be seeing a similar process in action in the NFL. Between Green Bay, New England and New Orleans, there were at least three very successful, very unbalanced teams this year. All three defenses were terrible in distinct and intermittently dazzling ways, but all three teams achieved the same result: looking terrible for much of the game, and winning anyway. Recent history shows that an inept offense can evolve to live off a superlative defense as well; Trent Dilfer would be the guy to talk to about this.

But in a more localized, black-and-gold context, the Vernon Davis slant that ended the Saints’ season, may also have ended an era. Instead of being run out of town, remora-pilot Gregg Williams left to run the St. Louis defense. In his place, Steve Spagnuolo, who actually was run out of St. Louis, will be taking over the Saints defense, and bringing his DC along to coach the Saints defensive backs. Pretty much everyone involved got a demotion.

After years of profanity-laced study, I don’t see how the defense that the Saints ran during the DBHOTF years could exist anywhere else; if there is a fish that exists off of remoras, it isn’t the kind of fish that one analogizes to winners. Regardless, the brand of Saints football that I’ve had so much fun watching for the last six years necessarily included a defense, and the GWIME was the defense that it had. It was flawed, silly, prone to failure but capable of occasional majesty and, for all its faults, perfectly suited to thrive in its unique niche.

Whatever the Saints do next year, it won’t be the same. The offense as it exists may be unaffordable—Brees, disgruntled All-Pro guard Carl Nicks and top wideout Marques Colston are all free agents. If the changed environment leads to fewer points, the GWIME will have to evolve or die. By the same token, if the offense and defense both regress towards the NFL mean, it doesn’t mean that the team will lose. But it does mean that the gonzo, high-variance, definitely-bet-the-over Saints games of recent years will be replaced by the same boring crap that, say, Falcons fans have been watching. If the Saints start winning that way, I guess I’ll enjoy the wins. But I think I’ll miss the screaming.

Share |


This is the fitting weblog for anybody who needs to find out about this topic. You notice so much its nearly onerous to argue with you (not that I really would want…HaHa). You positively put a brand new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Nice stuff, simply nice! biostar motherboard review

Awesome work! That is quite appreciated. I hope you’ll get more success. url opener

So lot to occur over your amazing blog. Your blog procures me a fantastic transaction of enjoyable.. Salubrious lot beside the scene. Trader Salary

It’s my first time to visit this site & I’m really surprised to see such impressive stuff out there.


Hello, this is fastidious post I actually loved
opulence for life bonus

Great! We will be connecting to this enormous post on our site. Continue the good writing.
project yourself Amish Shah

The most interesting text on this interesting topic that can be found on the net ... Obsession Phrases

Hey nice post man! Thanks for incredible info.
opulence for life bonus

This article has some vast and valuable information about this subject.

I’m trampled by your contents carry on the wonderful work. push button influence bonus

I truly appreciate your working guys, thumbs up!!

Great! We will be connecting to this enormous post on our site. Continue the good writing. olimpiadas 2016

Your blogs and every other content are thus interesting and helpful it makes me return back again.
discount car insurance

It’s my fortune to go to at this blog and realize out my required stuff that is also in the quality.cheap car insurance for minors

This is really an excellent blog as well as its content.Virtual Ceo Lifestyle

Your website is terribly informative and your articles are wonderful.http://www.personalcashadvance.com

Your articles are more than wow! And also the best way to make understand the things mentioned in it.
Macfarlane Group website

Your articles are more than wow! And also the best way to make understand the things mentioned in it.
Macfarlane Group

Your articles are more than wow! And also the best way to make understand the things mentioned in it.
payday loans in santa clarita ca

This written piece gives fastidious understanding yet.online payday loans no credit check

I was getting bore since morning but as soon as I got this link & reached at this blog, I turned into fresh and also joyful too.
Anik Singal

I was searching for decisive information on this topic. The information you have provided in the blog is really important.
Xvideos Porno

Thanks for compiling such nicest information in your blogs. Articles are very informative and hope again I’ll find more like that.
Xvideos Brasil

I have spent a lot of the time in different blogs but this is really a unique blog for me.Inbox blueprint 2.0 review

I went over this site and I trust you have a considerable measure of superb data, spared to my bookmarks http://cccamserver16.nation2.com/

It is fine, nonetheless evaluate the information and facts around this correct. Lovetraction Lines Review

Probably all they really wanted. You did get a free public education. Obviously you were not paying attention in class.
cubefield 2
scary games
happy wheels demo
fireboy and watergirl 5
super smash flash
temple run online

I was getting bore since morning but as soon as I got this link & reached at this blog, I turned into fresh and also joyful too.
buying soundcloud views

It’s amazing to visit again n again coming to your blogs the superb effort is here.
how to get more plays on soundcloud 2015

Hey nice post man! Thanks for incredible info.
commercify bonus

Your articles are very well written and unique.

The quality of your blogs and conjointly the articles and price appreciating.

I'm also visiting this site regularly, this web site is really nice and the users are genuinely sharing good thoughts.


Hi I was searching for the blogs for many times, now I have reached at the right place.
Mark Curry website

If somebody wants expert take on the main topic of blogging next I advise him/her to go to this site, continue the fussy job.
Shailendra Singh Sequoia Capital India

Quickly this site will indisputably be famous among all blogging people, because of its fastidious articles or reviews.

Louis, will be taking over the Saints defense, and bringing his DC along to coach the Saints defensive backs. Pretty much everyone involved got a demotion.
summoners war crystal hack |
clash of clans hack online

Thanks for writing such a good article, I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing... hormone doctor

This blog is truly extraordinary in all aspects.
auto insurance

These you will then see the most important thing, the application provides you a website a powerful important internet page: The Psystrology Method Review

Your composing is purely awe-inspiring that I desired to read such high quality material...

Exceptional blog you guys have conserved there, I absolutely appraise your effort.
buy real soundcloud plays

I invite you to the page where you can read with interesting information on similar topics. Obsession Phrases

Cool blog site friend I'm about to suggest this to all my listing contacts. club flyers

Every week-end I used to pay a fast visit this site, because I’d like enjoyment, because this web site conations certainly fussy material.
how to get more plays on soundcloud 2015

Thanks meant for sharing this type of satisfying opinion, written piece is fastidious, that’s why I’ve read it completely.
getting more plays on soundcloud

Quality stuff may be the key to invite the users to visit begin to see the blog site, that’s what this site provides.
home and auto insurance bundle

I’m reading the stuff of your site continuously n I have got really a lot of the things that’s very important. You have put the great effort here.
Venture capital

This written piece gives fastidious understanding yet.timothy marcus trade fusion

I would be supportive on all your articles and blogs as a result of they are simply up to the mark.