Brawl Games

A people's history of athletes and fans getting awful with each other, and a reminder that Metta World Peace did not invent violence.
Share |
The horror. The horror. Is actually fairly well-rendered.

"Aubernica" image via the legendary Wizznutzz.

Whenever there’s mayhem on the playing surface—be it NHL headhunting, NFL bonuses for headhunting, or Metta World Peace's notably more literal assault on James Harden's head—the 24-hour sports-industrial-media-complex and the comments-section commentariat go wild. [Recent event] is a new low; it wasn’t like this in the old days; thugs are destroying the game we love; where have you gone Joe DiMaggio and et cetera.

It's ridiculous, but it's also wrong. This latest round of violence is bad stuff—and the NBA should give the artist formerly known as Ron Artest a long vacation—but it's all far from unprecedented. Sports violence didn’t start with Raffi Torres' sociopathy or Gregg Williams' bonuses or MWP/Ron Artest's elbow. Below is a feature I wrote for the Roanoke Times back in 2004, after MWP's previous episode of in-game ultra-violence. This was a different assault and a different situation, of course. But the puffed-up moralizing and clucking over the new violence in our once-pure sports scene are, perhaps unsurprisingly, something very much like the same old story.


Fans howled as he charged into the stands, a mad bull, his eyes burning with mayhem. He was a manchild who'd learned to use his fists on the mean streets of the inner city, and nobody, nobody, was going to disrespect him. He was a big-time athlete, his pockets stuffed with more money than the average fan could imagine. They might've paid for their tickets, but that didn't give them the right to insult his manhood.

So Babe Ruth plunged into the crowd.

Ruth was going after a fan who’d heckled him after Ruth had been thrown out at second and then tossed out of the game for flinging dirt in the umpire's face. "You goddamned big bum, why don't you play ball?" the heckler had yelled.

After Ruth jumped onto the dugout roof and came at him, the loudmouthed fan scurried out of reach. Ruth clambered back onto the dugout, his face red, his hair matted. "Come on down and fight!" The Babe bellowed. "Anyone who wants to fight, come down on the field! Ah, you're all alike, you're all yellow!"

Ruth failed to catch his heckler that muggy, "bad-tempered day" in the spring of 1922. But a decade before, Ty Cobb, the man who'd preceded Ruth as the national pastime's greatest star, had more luck. Cobb vaulted the guardrail protecting the grandstand, stalked up 12 rows and began punching and kicking a heckler, tearing holes with his spikes and opening gashes around the man's ears and face.

Other spectators pleaded with Cobb, yelling that the man—who'd lost eight fingers in an industrial accident—had no hands. "I don't care if he has no feet," Cobb replied.

Flash forward, into another century, and newspapers, magazines and TV screens are filled with images of NBA bad-boy Ron Artest rampaging into the stands of a basketball megaplex in Detroit, swinging at fans. He's enraged over getting hit with a cup hurled by a spectator. Fights swirl between fans and players. A chair sails through the air.

ESPN runs the footage again and again. USA Today calls it the "player-fan brawl that shocked the nation." It was, one fan tells the newspaper, "like the 9/11 of the NBA." Sports Illustrated calls it a "frightening wake-up call." The Chicago Sun-Times calls it an exemplar of an "escalating crisis of violence in sports."

It's as if nothing like this has ever happened before, as if, suddenly, shockingly, the once-glorious game is being trampled upon by a new-sprung wave of pretenders and barbarians. In the mythology of American sports, there was a simpler time, a Golden Era, when ballplayers were humble and worked hard and played for the love of the game. In these innocent times, sports were all but unpolluted by greed, egos, cheating and violence. The flip side of this mythos is the idea that today's athletes are different: arrogant, spoiled, lazy, overpaid, brutish.

This is a conviction built on historical amnesia, on a romanticized view of the past and an alarmist view of the present. It's an outlook that ignores these well-documented facts: Sports have always been violent. And they've always been populated by considerable numbers of players and fans who can't behave themselves.

All the elements of today's crisis in sports are there, in the record of more than a century of American sports: Riots on and off the field . . . greed and commercialism and racism . . . swellheaded, selfish superstars . . . fans attacking players and players attacking fans . . . beanballs and intentional cheap shots . . . off-the-field misconduct by gun-wielding, wife-beating, law-breaking athletes . . . fans hurling beer bottles, chair slats, knives, batteries, billiard balls and other missiles at players.

It's easy to find these facts, if you know where to look. Read Robert Creamer's biography of The Babe (the source of the tale of Ruth's 1922 tantrum), or thumb through Richard Scheinin's meticulous work, Field of Screams: The Dark Underside of America's National Pastime (which documents a long list of misdeeds by Ty Cobb and other baseballers).

Check out Terry Pluto's Tall Tales, about the "glory years" of the National Basketball Association, and hear the memories of George Yardley, a veteran of those bygone days: "I must have had about 80 stitches in my face, all from things that happened on the court. Guys would hit you with a clenched fist, just cutting your skull open. Over the years, I played with at least 40 different guys and I can't name one who had all of his own teeth."

Or open Stuart Leuthner's oral history of the "golden days" of pro football, Iron Men, and listen to Jim Ringo, who grappled in the National Football League's trenches in the 1950s and '60s: "I started to clean up when I retired, but there wasn't a game when we didn't get into a fight… If you took the same mayhem that is created out on that field down to some street corner or in a bar, they'd lock you up for 20 years."

None of this excuses the out-of-control conduct of Artest, his Indiana Pacers teammates, or their Detroit Pistons opponents. And it doesn't excuse the conduct of the Clemson and University of South Carolina football players who brawled the day after the NBA fracas, providing more videotaped evidence for the sports-have-reached-a- low-point argument.

These athletes provided sorry examples for children who look up to them as heroes. Everyone agrees something needs to be done to address violence in sports. Punishments meted out. Rules laid down. But if we want to understand the problem, and figure out what we're going to do about it, we have to understand the nature of violence and sports and their long, intertwined history. That's not easy, because nostalgia, race, selective memory and the changing face of the media all influence how we judge today's concerns—and how we compare them to the problems of the past.

Roland Lazenby, a Virginia Tech communications professor, watched the Nov. 19 Pistons-Pacers melee live on TV with his 15-year-old daughter. He saw it (as he told USA Today) as "a breakdown in the social order." But he also understood he wasn't watching something unprecedented. He's spent two decades writing books about basketball and interviewing its pioneers.

Basketball, Lazenby knows, has been haunted by portents of mayhem, from the time of its invention in 1891 and through the history of the NBA. "Basketball is a very passionate, hot-blooded, fast-paced game," Lazenby says. "The game's always had its potential to boil over." The same can be said, he says, for other sports.


Around the time James Naismith was inventing basketball, Clemson and South Carolina universities were in the early stages of a football rivalry that would produce a televised riot more than a century later.

By 1902, emotions had reached a perilous pitch. After a 12-6 Carolina triumph, a series of brutal melees broke out among fans. Finally, Clemson's student cadets marched on South Carolina's campus with bayonets and swords. Thirty South Carolina students arrayed themselves behind a low wall, with clubs and cocked pistols. A South Carolina coach stalled for time, offering to fight, man to man, with any cadet the Clemson corps selected. This gave authorities time to arrive and forge a truce. As John Sayle Watterson writes in his epic history, College Football, the two sides "ended up cheering for each other, evidently oblivious to the bloodshed that had nearly occurred."

Dirty play, on-field deaths and unruly crowds were commonplace in football before and after the turn of the century. The first football contest between black colleges in Tennessee was broken up by drunken whites. A race riot ensued. One black spectator died.

Racism tinged much of the sport-related violence that came in the 20th century. In 1910, Jack Johnson became the first black man to win the heavyweight boxing title, an event so earth-shattering it sparked race riots around the country that produced 19 deaths, 251 injuries and more than 5,000 arrests. Many of Ty Cobb's worst assaults sprung from his race hatred. He kicked a chambermaid in the stomach and pushed her down a flight of stairs after she objected to being called "nigger." He beat a black groundskeeper and choked the man's wife when she tried to intervene.

Whites felt his wrath, too. He pointed a gun at a butcher's head. He kneed hecklers in the groin. "I fight only one way, and that's to kill," he said before slamming an umpire's head again and again into concrete.

The punishments he earned for these acts were minimal. His brutality didn't prevent him from being a golfing partner with President Taft or becoming the first player elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame.

Of course, Cobb was far from the only big leaguer with a mean streak. In 1912, the Boston Red Sox beat their own rookie pitcher so mercilessly after he'd lost a World Series game, 2-1, that he never pitched effectively again. In 1929, Art "The Great" Shires punched his manager in the eye during the Chicago White Sox's spring training. He slugged the manager a second time after the season began. He wasn't suspended until his third assault—he punched out his manager and heaved liquor bottles at police when they tried to stop him from trashing a hotel room.

The Chicago Cubs' Billy Jurges spoke of the fights and dirty plays that were routine in the game in the years before World War II: "A lot of guys would hate you. Really hate you… It was part of baseball."


Basketball's early years were marked by uneasy relationships between players and fans. Players came to be known as cagers because their courts were encased in mesh. The idea was to keep the ball from going out of bounds—and to keep fans and players apart.

Fans got around the mesh by heating nails and pennies with matches and lighters and then flinging them at players. In the 1940s, Lazenby notes, hockey owners created modern professional basketball out of a desire to fill their arenas on off nights. As in hockey, they encouraged players to fight. That was part of the draw for fans.

The fights didn't stop as the league outgrew its blue-collar roots. In the first game of the 1966-67 NBA season, New York Knicks center Willis Reed punched out one Los Angeles Laker after another. "He just took over. The most unbelievable fight I ever saw in basketball," one sportswriter recalls in Lazenby's oral history of the Lakers, The Show.

Two seasons later, Reed was in the middle of things again as a Knicks game against the Atlanta Hawks game punctuated by four fights that spread over three quarters. In the final period, both teams ended up brawling before order seemed to be restored. Then two players—the Knicks' Nate Bowman and the Hawks' Bill Bridges—resumed combat and spilled into the front row. "Bowman flattened Bridges, a fan grabbed Bowman and Bridges got in an answer-lick," The New York Times reported at the time. One of the brawlers, Paul Silas, recalled recently in the Charlotte Observer that the resulting punishments were modest: No one paid more than $25 in fines.

Things were much the same in the NBA's rival, the now-defunct American Basketball Association. During the 1971-72 season, police charged Virginia Squires coach Al Bianchi and two of his players with assault after a Squires-Pacers brawl in which players, police, coaches and fans wrestled and threw punches. As Bianchi recalled in the Arizona Republic, he pulled a police officer off one of his players and then threw the cop over the scorer's table: "Suddenly the officer disappears. Come to find out, he ended up in the fourth row where two of our guys threw him."


The 1970s saw no letup in the violence that stalked big-time sports. "More and more," Scheinin writes in Field of Screams, his unsunny history of baseball, "there were reports of players storming into the stands after hecklers. And more and more, there were reports of players donning batting helmets for protection in the field against beer showers and debris thrown by spectators."

In 1972, an Ohio State-Minnesota basketball game turned into a melee when a Minnesota player offered a hand to an opponent, then kneed him in the groin. Both teams charged onto the floor and a throng of Minnesota fans attacked and bloodied Ohio State's players. Ohio's governor called it "Gang warfare in an athletic arena."

In 1977, an NBA brawl turned scary when the Lakers' Kermit Washington floored the Houston Rockets' Rudy Tomjanovich with a blow to the face. "The Punch," as it's come to be known, put Tomjanovich in the hospital for weeks and ended his playing career. The league suspended Washington for 26 games, the longest penalty for on-court misconduct until this fall, when Artest was suspended for the final 73 games of the season.

The stories of violence have continued over the past two decades. Two years ago a father and son ran onto the diamond in Chicago and slammed a Kansas City Royals first-base coach to the ground, punching and kicking him. In September, Texas Rangers' pitcher Frankie Francisco, incensed by a heckler, threw a chair into the stands and broke a woman's nose.


Today's relentless electronic media document and magnify these fits of rage, capturing them on video and replaying them endlessly on 24-hour TV channels, in detail and living color that weren't available in the days of Babe Ruth or Ty Cobb. It's hard not to believe things are getting worse, that players and fans are out of control and traditions of the game are breaking down. Most of us want to believe that, once upon a time, things were better. And we tend to believe that our problems are unique: nothing like this ever happened before.

Journalists angle their stories toward what's new and trend-setting rather than what's commonplace and timeless. They churn out news stories with headlines like this one: "Bad sports take hold where civility once thrived." Few ask: Are these bad behaviors new? Or are they perpetual problems?

Or, simply: are things really worse? Are athletes more arrogant and contemptuous of ticket buyers today than players were in the 1950s, when the Boston Red Sox's icily masterful hitter, Ted Williams, spit at his hometown fans and gave them the finger? (Off-duty Boston cops were said to give boys apples to throw at Williams.)

Are players more pugnacious today than they were in 1957, when the New York Yankees engaged in three bench-clearing brawls in a single week? (That same season, after a Dodgers-Reds brawl, one of the gladiators told the press his plans for his main antagonist: "I'll get him. I'll whip his hide and his wife won't know him when I get through.")

Are fans more unruly today than they were in Cleveland in 1974, when the Indians and Rangers had to unite and use their bats as weapons to fend off a crazed, knife-wielding Ten Cent Beer Night crowd? (Rangers manager Billy Martin said it was "the closest I ever saw to someone getting killed in baseball.")

Glyn Hughes, a sociologist at the University of Richmond, believes much of the concern that today's athletes are spoiled and violent is wrapped up in unspoken, sometimes unconscious racial beliefs. The complaints that athletes don't respect authority or are "too hip-hop," Hughes says, are code words for saying they're "too black." Fans who hark back to the good old days of big-time sports, he says, are harkening back to a time when the games happened to be almost lily white.

Ronald Smith, a retired Penn State historian and former college athlete himself, has studied the annals of sports for decades. The idea of a golden age, he says, is "a bunch of baloney." He's glad Artest was suspended for his part in the Pacers-Pistons rumble. But Smith doesn't see that what Artest did—reacting wildly to getting hit by an object thrown by a fan—is as bad as the premeditated violence that has long been a part of sports: beanballs thrown behind batters' heads or deliberate maimings designed to put star players out of games.

One such episode was an attack on Johnny Bright, one of college football's first great black stars. In 1951, the Drake University running back had established himself as the college game's all-time leading rusher. On the first play from scrimmage in a game with Oklahoma A&M, Bright was away from the action when a defensive lineman sought him out and smashed him in the face with a forearm. Bright tried to play on, but the assault effectively ended his career.

And even though game films clearly showed the lineman had gone out of his way to attack Bright, conference administrators refused to discipline the A&M team.


In the aftermath of the Pacers-Pistons brawl, sports commentators tried to dissect the man whose rampage cost him nearly $5 million in lost salary. The Chicago Sun-Times' Rick Telander painted Ron Artest as an "impulsive child." When Artest "feels or sees something, he just reacts to it," his former agent said. "There's not a whole lot of taking a deep breath and thinking about what he's going to do. He just does it."

In another century, a sportswriter would recall Babe Ruth this way: "He was the most uninhibited being I have ever known. He just did things."

Ruth womanized, broke curfew, gorged on hot dogs before games, cursed and punched umpires and once was so drunk at spring training that he ran into a palm tree in the outfield and knocked himself senseless. He was a big enough star, though, that the rules didn't really apply to him. On one occasion he saved himself from getting benched for boozing and carousing by smacking two home runs in a game. "How can I fine and suspend him the way he played today?" his manager asked.

And Ruth's 1922 foray into the stands after a heckler? It cost him a one-game suspension and a $200 fine. He said he didn't deserve any punishment. "I did mean to hit that bastard in the stands," he told reporters. "I'll go into the stands again if I have to." He'd taken as much as he could. "I had to break loose," The Babe said.

Share |


In 2001 Siamak Bay, a university graduate in agriculture and plant breeding, established Greenbay Northern Landscaping in richmond hill. At first with a small crew (less than 10) he provided lawn and garden services, but soon Greenbay Northern Landscaping expanded by hiring more skilled staff to fulfill the demand for all type of landscape services including; landscape design, paving stone interlocking, retaining walls, pool and patio, custom fence and deck and etc.. Having responsible and knowledgeable staff is a major part of our success. Siamak’s dream of a full service company materialized faster than his own expectation. Greenbay Northern is proud to say that it has many happy and satisfied customers. Strong handshakes with the phrase “You have delivered beyond my expectation” are proof to us that we once again have met our goal in customer service. Please visit our gallery to see our love for nature, our art work, our passion. We will be pleased to sit down with you, listen to your expectations and deliver the best.aurora landscapingn

laser clinic toronto
The Ideal Dream Laser Clinic is a cosmetic-medical center offering only certified, result-oriented hair removal, Skin rejuvenating, body countering and weight loss services for both men and women. Our team includes certified technicians, Registered Dietitian and specialized skin and laser consultants. We offer the highest level of safety and service in an environment where the main priority is your safety, health and privacy. Our clinic located in heart of north York , Yonge and Steeles area close to public transit. 5 min walk to center of Yonge and Steeles, 88 Steeles Ave. East Toronto.

hiring a pr firm
I have read your article, it is very informative and helpful for me.I admire the valuable information you offer in your articles. Thanks for posting it..

media coverage
Realistic and simple. This is the thing that I want. Keeep doing . Loving this.

It is basic that we read blog entry painstakingly. I am as of now done it and find this post is truly astounding. ladies shoes

This substance is composed exceptionally well. Your utilization of organizing when mentioning your focuses makes your objective facts clear and straightforward. Much obliged to you. cheap italian clothes online

brake disc
hi was just seeing if you minded a comment. i like your website and the thme you picked is super. I will be back.

much thanks to you for your intriguing infomation. Make him miss you

As the power of PageRank is getting lower, flow metrics matter. Google gives a huge importance to metrics like domain authority, trust flow or citation flow as a ranking factor. high trust flow

Your website is really cool and this is a great inspiring article. Thank you so much. How To Ride A Guy

laser clinic north york
The Ideal Dream Laser Clinic is a cosmetic-medical center offering only certified, result-oriented hair removal, Skin rejuvenating, body countering and weight loss services for both men and women. Our team includes certified technicians, Registered Dietitian and specialized skin and laser consultants. We offer the highest level of safety and service in an environment where the main priority is your safety, health and privacy. Our clinic located in heart of north York , Yonge and Steeles area close to public transit. 5 min walk to center of Yonge and Steeles, 88 Steeles Ave. East Toronto.

This is my first time i visit here. I discovered such a large number of fascinating stuff in your web journal particularly its discourse. From the huge amounts of remarks on your articles, I figure I am by all account not the only one having all the delight here! keep doing awesome 21 Questions

Greenbay Northern landscaping is located in Richmond Hill we provide service anywhere from Newmarket to North York including ;Markham, Maple and Vaughn.aurora landscapingn

Its an incredible joy perusing your post.Its brimming with data I am searching for and I want to post a remark that "The substance of your post is amazing" Great work. His Secret Obsession

hello!! Very interesting discussion glad that I came across such informative post. Keep up the good work friend. Glad to be part of your net community. dirty questions to ask a guy

I might want to thank you for the endeavors you have made in composing this article. I am trusting the same best work from you later on also.. How To Make Him Miss You

I simply discovered this online journal and have high trusts in it to proceed. Keep up the immense work, its elusive great ones. I have added to my top picks. Much obliged to You. 600 Dofollow High Blog Comment

Thanks for sharing nice information with us. I really liked this part of the article, This is truly awesome article..!!
private carding forum

Your thing is shows latent, m gona add this to my bookmarks. Boston Plumber

We are truly thankful for your blog entry. You will discover a great deal of methodologies in the wake of going to your post. I was precisely scanning for. A debt of gratitude is in order for such post and please keep it up..!
moveis planejados zona norte

You make such a large number of incredible focuses here that I read your article two or three times. Your perspectives are as per my own particular generally. This is extraordinary substance for your perusers. Love Text

Cool stuff you have and you keep overhaul every one of us. elderly care in anderson

Incredible substance material and extraordinary design. Your site merits the majority of the positive criticism it's been gett remote starters

The substance you are penning blows out my nous. poker online terpercaya

We are truly thankful for your blog entry. You will discover a great deal of methodologies in the wake of going to your post. I was precisely scanning for. A debt of gratitude is in order for such post and please keep it up
Accountants East Grinstead

If you don't mind fill me in regarding whether you're searching for an article essayist for your site. You have some truly incredible posts and I feel I would be a decent resource. On the off chance that you ever need to take a portion of the heap off, I'd completely love to compose some material for your web journal in return for a connection back to mine. If it's not too much trouble send me an email if intrigued. Much obliged to you! How To Kiss A Man To Make Him Fall In Love

On the off chance that more individuals that compose articles truly fretted about composing incredible substance like you, more perusers would be occupied with their works. Much obliged to you for thinking about your substance. His Secret Obsession

Incredible data! I as of late went over your online journal and have been perusing along. I thought I would leave my first remark. I don't realize what to say with the exception of that I have. domino qq

Superb and extremely energizing site. Adoration to watch. Continue Rocking. right breast pain

I like the valuable information you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your blog and check again here frequently. I"m quite certain I will learn many new stuff right here! Best of luck for the next! Thank you for share.Self Assessment Tax Return

Distributing brochures can fit in any solid marketing strategy. cheap flyer printing san jose ca

I havent any word to value this post.....Really i am inspired from this post....the individual who make this post it was an extraordinary human..thanks for imparted this to us. Lovetraction Lines

This is the sort of data I've long been attempting to discover. Much obliged to you for composing this data. Mikrowelle unterbaufähig

I simply discovered this online journal and have high trusts in it to proceed. Keep up the immense work, its elusive great ones. I have added to my top picks. Much obliged to You. 600 Dofollow High Blog Comment

Brilliant site joined with extraordinary top quality items and furthermore I'm sure this will be hugely gainful Site:

Your work is great and I welcome you and jumping for some more useful posts. Much obliged to you for sharing extraordinary data to us. franchise marketing automation software

I enjoy to translate and revalue your transmute. sati

Good focuses you composed here..Great stuff...I think you've made some really intriguing points.Keep up the great work. How to get an ex back

A good blog always comes-up with new and exciting information and while reading I have feel that this blog is really have all those quality that qualify a blog to be a one. plastic cable carrier

I don't cerebrate some of websites offer this typewrite of assemblage. cccam server

I will really appreciate the writer's choice for choosing this excellent article appropriate to my matter.Here is deep description about the article matter which helped me more. فينير

This is a savvy blog. I would not joke about this. You have such a great amount of learning about this issue, thus much enthusiasm. You additionally know how to make individuals rally behind it, clearly from the reactions.
harvey norman chadstone

it's really nice and meanful. it's really cool blog. Linking is very useful have really helped lots of people who visit blog and provide them usefull information.
best portable solar panels

We are tied directly into the sate’s renewal database which allows us to process your request almost instantly. Certificate Translation

The site is looking piece ostentatious and it gets the guests eyes. Outline is really basic and a decent easy to use interface. Gas&Air

Such a very useful article. Very interesting to read this article.I would like to thank you for the efforts you had made for writing this awesome article. Project Hotel Furniture

This is a savvy blog. I would not joke about this. You have such a great amount of learning about this issue, thus much enthusiasm. You additionally know how to make individuals rally behind it, clearly from the reactions. buy fb followers

Movies" would probably be about the history of entertaining movies and blockbusters. popcornflix

A debt of gratitude is in order for setting aside an ideal opportunity to examine this, I feel emphatically about it and love adapting more on this theme. In the event that conceivable, as you pick up aptitude, would you mind upgrading your web journal with additional data? It is greatly useful for me. escort in beirut

had more luck. Cobb vaulted the guardrail protecting the grandstand, stalked up 12 rows and began punching and kicking a heckler, tearing holes with his spikes and opening gashes around the man's ears and face.minecraft en francais |
codes psn free