About that Map of Positions

Rethinking the rethinking of players' roles in basketball (again).
Share |

The Alagappan Plan [Image via Gizmodo]

Muthu Alagappan's scatter-plot of new positional definition made its way to Deadspin (via Gizmodo) this weekend, after first rearing its head at the Sloan Conference. Drawing on the methods of biomechanical engineering, Alagappan groups today's NBA players according to function and, in some cases, sheer quality. We get several distinct clusters of "ball-handlers," as well as "role players" and "All-NBA"—not to mention the soaring catch-all of "one-of-a-kind."

This is the latest, and certainly the most rigorous attempt to change the way we think about positions by determining a new set of categories. In Alagappan's case, the categories are drawn from the real-life data at hand. Positions are derived inductively, according to the facts on the ground, rather than deductively assigned according to transcendent forms and archetypes.

The problem, as I see it, is that this reversal of poles runs the risk of very quickly collapsing on itself. It's unclear, for instance, when a new category is set to emerge if the ultimate authority here is real-life teams. The model, then, is only as good as the latest trends—still an impressive accomplishment, but one far more fleeting than any remotely fixed redefinition of position. The system has become its own point of reference, rather than appealing to codes or languages set down by years of supposedly inflexible tradition.

Once this happens, the system is free to contort and fragment itself however it sees fit. We’ve seen how this story goes in other realms of human inquiry: structuralism gives way to post-structuralism, where positions are defined only in reference to each other on a team-by-team, or possession-by-possession, basis. I was told once by a member of the Thunder organization that often, their players shift "position" several times over the course of a play. At that point, what exactly is the point of definition, much less labels that make sense across the sport?

Rob Mahoney directed our attention to the strange case of Tyreke Evans. Evans, the 2010 Rookie of the Year and once the future of the Sacramento Kings, has spent most of his career trying to learn how to play point guard (pure point guards and centers, whose roles have always been firmly conceptual, do a mighty good job of surviving any and all revisionism of the Old Ways), and instead, shown that he's some sort of combo guard (whatever that means—it changes constantly) to the death.

The Kings have tried pairing him with a variety of backcourt partners whose shooting or playmaking could make up for Evans's one-on-one mentality. But Evans remained the poor man’s point guard: dominating the ball, initiating the offense, and scoring like it wasn't an end in itself. Now, Evans has been moved over to small forward, but absolutely nothing has changed. As Mahoney puts it:

A player's nominal position often isn't always dictated by what he can or can't do, but by who he plays alongside. We've become so locked into the notion that basketball is a five-position enterprise that successful lineups simply have to feature one of each traditional position type.

Evans isn't an idea, he's a dude playing with some other dudes. It's all fine and good to try and search for absolute labels, or at least relatively stable ones, but when the Kings can make this kind of move and have it be news, it's pretty obvious that positions are almost entirely arbitrary. The success of a team isn't determined by whether or not they measure up, formula-wise, but whether their assemblage works, in an almost mechanical sense. Or—if you hate technology-speak—if these distinctive organisms can work together as a colony.

I used to be a positional relativist, with players’ roles determined by a set of responsibilities that had to be distributed across the roster. However, this now seems way too rigid, as it locates the possibility of unflinching order somewhere between a team's identity and the identity of the individual players—neither of which was supposed to slip or crumble. Now I would say I'm more of a positional anarchist, but not in the violent, liberal-arts-kids gone wild, sense. I'm thinking more of the utopian version of anarchism, where everyone is provided precisely through the rejection of overarching order or authority.  

If you look at the marvel that is this year's Heat, the team has learned harmony through each of the Big Three staking out territory and working together based on this division of space, not labor. Labor was what I once thought to be the basic currency of positions; it's what I imagined the Heat would revolutionize, and what manifested itself in such ugly ways when LeBron and Wade dourly traded possessions, or quarters, last season. Instead, it's about giving players room to operate, and then piecing together a viable community out of this. It's what I thought the Knicks should have been able to do with Carmelo, Lin, and D'Antoni; it's the only coherent way to understand an OKC team lambasted for its lack of an offensive system but which apparently thinks about position in an extremely sophisticated way.

Maybe this only holds true for the best players, the "All-NBA" and "one-of-a-kind" creatures on Alagappan's map. Still, I want to believe that less, not more, complexity is the only way to adequately let players do what they do best while still allowing a team to go about the business of winning basketball games.  


Share |

Comments

I am confident you've got a great enthusiast following there.

virtual ceo lifestyle

the poor man’s point guard: dominating the ball, initiating the offense, and scoring like it wasn't an end in itself. Now, Evans has been moved over to small forward, but absolutely nothing has changed. As Mahoney puts it:
clas of clan

Your articles are more than wow! And also the best way to make understand the things mentioned in it. increase domains authority

Whatever I thought this blog is such like that, more awesome, more attractive, more eye-catching.
life insurance rates

Thank you so much that you provide something special for us that not only can help in our studies but also help to learn in the practical life.
car insurance rates

This is a great post; it was very edifying. I look ahead in reading more of your work.
Affordable club flyers

The quality of the blog is truly remarkable, I love your informative blog thanks!
http://www.toursmiamitokeywest.com

I actually spend my little time to read the websites but this blog is quite different from others, this has helped me a lot in my work. Thanks
cash advance

I actually spend my little time to read the websites but this blog is quite different from others, this has helped me a lot in my work. Thanks
cash advance

Way cool some valid points! I am grateful for you making this post on hand; the rest of this website is also first-class. Have a great fun.
Curry

It’s a classic great for me to go to this blog site, it offers helpful suggestions attorney stuart fl

Nobody can reject the info you have given in the blogs, this is actually a great work.million dollar business secrets harv eker review

I constantly emailed this site post page to all my friends, because if prefer to read it then my all friends will too.http://www.lifeinsurancerates.com

This is really awesome and i love that.. This is very unique thing you put on that post.. Thanks for sharing. Dota 2 mmr boosting

Your blog is extremely brilliant especially the quality content is really appreciable. car insurance discounts

I really enjoy reading and also appreciate your work.
short term payday loans

Watching them gain traction and understanding as they find their online' identities within 140 character contraints, bullet points and images it's what I love most about my job! newtown

I actually spend my little time to read the websites but this blog is quite different from others, this has helped me a lot in my work. Thanks
mind movie matrix bonuses

Hi buddies, it is great written piece entirely defined, continue the good work constantly.http://virtualceolifestylebonuses.com

I really like your post. It is good to see you verbalize from the cardiovascular and clarity on this important subject can be easily observed. You have provided great information in your post a fantastic read

I even have been gifted for hours and I haven't suffered such awesome stuff.
Macfarlane Group

Nice to be visiting your blog again, it has been months for me. Well this article that i've been waited for so long. I need this article to complete my assignment in the college, and it has same topic with your article. Thanks, great share. fencarlota.inube.com/blog/4923600/captain-america-civil-war-stream/

Keep the ball rolling you have done the great job here.virtualceolifestyle.net

I sent your articles links to all my contacts and they all adore it including me.thyroid supplements

There are many ways to do a blogger to survive. However, for a blogger, keep in touch with many people is a way to live. Blogger is a choide for a person. www.katanaibcbet.com/cara-login/

From there, Aliso Creek bends west and enters Aliso Canyon, which cuts through the San Joaquin Hills on the creek's final run to the sea. Wakefield

It’s amazing in support of me to truly have a blog site, which will be valuable meant for my knowledge. Thanks admin.Inbox blueprint 2.0

Hi Dear, have you been certainly visiting this site daily, if that's the case you then will certainly get good knowledge.personalcashadvance.com

This is only the data I am discovering all around. A debt of gratitude is in order for your website, I simply subscribe your online journal. This is a decent blog.. https://cccamserver1.joomla.com/

I sent your articles links to all my contacts and they all adore it including me.forskolin for weight loss

Remarkable blog! I have no words to praise, it has really allured me.
Inbox blueprint 2.0 review

Thanks for Nice and Informative Post. This article is really contains lot more information about This Topic. scr888

So it is interesting and very good written and see what they think about other people. The Psystrology Method Review

I see the superlative contents on your blogs and I perfectly enjoy going through them.
happy wheels
cubefield
temple run
super smash flash 2
scary maze game
fireboy and watergirl

Hmm!! This blog is really cool, I’m so lucky that I have reached here and got this awesome information.
Inbox blueprint review

I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious, I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions, very curious. agen judi

It’s my first time to visit this site & I’m really surprised to see such impressive stuff out there.
what is my life insurance policy worth

Thanks for sharing short but very informative and friendly article! Best of luck to you.. agen judi liga spanyol

Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!! www.Jutasbobet.com/cara-daftar/

I really like your post. It is good to see you verbalize from the cardiovascular and clarity on this important subject can be easily observed. You have provided great information in your post. Link zu der Website

I'm also visiting this site regularly, this web site is really nice and the users are genuinely sharing good thoughts.click here

I sent your articles links to all my contacts and they all adore it including me.Via

Great blog you people have made here on this blog site, I will absolutely appreciate your work.
Mark Curry

Much obliged to you for such an elegantly composed article. It's brimming with quick data and captivating depictions. Your perspective is the best among numerous. medical assistant journal

I invite you to the page where you can read with interesting information on similar topics. How to Turn a Guy On Without Touching Him

It is certainly going to be even more powerful than it is now. Now most vehicle parts and accessories are available online for sale, including sbobet mobile

I personally liked going through your solid points on this topic. Many thanks for creating such excellent material. This is excellent... Los Angeles DUI attorney

Quickly this site will indisputably be famous among all blogging people, because of its fastidious articles or reviews.
personalcashadvance

I am very happy to read this article .. thanks for giving us go through info.Fantastic nice. I appreciate this post. paneles solares guatemala precios

What does Sandel mean by the Moral Limits of the Markets? Watch Stephen Colbert and Michael Sandel talk it over in the video! Watch using the embedded video player above simple payroll software