A People's History of Baseball

A special Labor Day weekend book excerpt
Share |
A People's History of Baseball

Courtesy of University of Illinois Press

Mitchell Nathanson's A People's History of Baseball is a rewarding detour from the usual sepia dad-whispering of diamond history. Nathanson, a legal scholar, looks at what he calls "counter-stories" from baseball's past and present to see how the simple myths of the game often mask power struggles and politics. After digging the excerpt, we have a bonus Q&A with Nathanson for your Labor Day embiggenment. Here's an excerpt from Chapter Five: "Wait Till Next Year" and the Denial of History.

Despite reality, which necessarily must conclude that underdogs have a less than equal chance of emerging victorious (if they did not, they would be favorites), many Americans somehow believe otherwise. This delusion allows us to preach high-mindedly but to remain disengaged from the struggle—for in our minds the downtrodden will emerge victorious on their own, without the need of aid. This mindset is consistent with American actions, as opposed to the verbal gymnastics used to nevertheless equate “American” values with support for the truly disadvantaged. In sports, the American penchant of rooting for the underdog really has more to do with rooting for the favorite in the mind’s eye—reality be damned. In life, traditional American attitudes toward disadvantaged groups (ones defined by an absence of the type of “looming success” that pervades the American definition of “underdog”) show little sympathy or empathy for actual victims of social injustice—Native and African Americans, immigrants, and women, to name but a few such groups. All of the perceived “American” values somehow fall by the wayside in the face of true disadvantage. It is therefore not surprising that the American definition of “underdog” does not extend far beyond the sports arena. In an athletic contest, we can sit passively in the stands holding firm to our stated beliefs without concern that we will be called upon to act on them. Once the game ends, however, and our beliefs have consequences, we are more likely to shy away from them.

In the end, it is not the underdog after all that Americans cherish. It is instead the optimism to believe that the underdog will win despite reasonable, concrete evidence to the contrary. Returning to the Australians for a moment, it becomes clear that besides a shared attraction to the term, Americans and Australians actually have very little in common when it comes to the national ethos supporting underdogs. Perhaps Americans are unique when it comes to our support for underdogs, but not in the way we normally assume. What may be unique about us (or at least unusual) is not our affection for the term but our delusion fueled by unwarranted optimism that underdogs will emerge victorious more often than not, even though by definition, they will not. It is this unwarranted optimism that, as it turns out, opens the door for what we would otherwise conclude are some very “un-American” behaviors by those claiming precisely the opposite allegiance.

For more than a century, unwarranted, irrational optimism has been seen by some of its critics and most ardent supporters alike as a diversionary device used to great effect to preserve the status quo and fend off change: the heroic stories of underdogs (from Horatio Alger’s tales onward) being fodder used to present the facade of overcoming even the most dire of situations, which in the process diverts attention from the world as it actually exists. With each underdog that emerges victorious, the focus remains on the extraordinary individual who accomplished the feat rather than on the situation that created the imbalance that necessitated the superhuman acts to surmount it. The psychologist and philosopher William James, although considered a “hero” of what would come to be known as the “positive thinking movement,” recognized as much a century ago when he noted that unfettered optimism and happiness presented potential dangers, given that they require “blindness and insensibility to opposing facts.” Although James did not conclude that such happiness was itself a sickness (indeed he believed it to be the socially desired state), the historian Donald Meyer noted that it led to a vulnerability to sickness if the achievement of a state of perpetual bliss became one’s overarching priority. In this way, the shutting out of opposing information and facts was, in James’s view, “wait ’til next year” and the denial of history under certain conditions “quasi-pathological”—although in his view this was not necessarily a bad thing. Several decades later Roth, a critic of the movement, would sound a similar, although more desolate, theme in The Great American Novel when his protagonist considered the magical pull of the word “America” and all it connotes: “America? … [W]hat’s America to you? Or to me? Or to those tens of thousands up in the stands? It’s just a word they use to keep your nose to the grindstone and your toes to the line. America is the opiate of the people …”

Sports, particularly baseball as well as the popular depiction of baseball as America, have helped to grease the wheels of the status quo through tales of triumphant underdogs to the point where that seventy-five-yearold Cubs fan could believe from the stands at Wrigley that this, irrespective of the last hundred, was the year his Cubbies were finally going to put it all together. This mindset, “quasi-pathological” at a minimum, is at its essence quintessentially American. Although the unquestioning devotion, the “blindness and insensibility to opposing facts,” ironically increases the likelihood of this fan’s perpetual misery (after all, there is little incentive for real change to occur if hope and optimism remain regardless of results), he is supportive nevertheless, for to abandon hope is contrary to the national character.

As it turns out, it is by design that this fan, along with countless others, feels this way and continues to look for roses—at the ballpark and, more importantly and with greater consequences, elsewhere—where there are only thorns. For as Americans we are the product of decades’ worth of rhetoric aimed directly at us with the goal of encouraging us to resign ourselves to the status quo and ignore our feelings of unease over our own place within the existing social structure; to give in and accept our fate rather than challenge a social and economic hierarchy where the overwhelming majority of wealth, power, and benefits reside with an ever-shrinking few. This rhetoric is evidenced within the baseball creed and has its roots in the societal upheaval caused by the rapid industrialization of America during the last half of the nineteenth century. The positive thinking movement would find a natural ally in baseball very early on as it attempted to calm the fears of those who had the means, numbers, and ability to overthrow the status quo if something was not done quickly.

Copyright 2012 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois. Used with permission of the University of Illinois Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be reprinted, photocopied, posted online or distributed in any way without the written permission of the copyright holder.

Share |


Excellent blog article.Really thanks! Cool.Im obliged for the blog.Really thanks! Significantly obliged.I really enjoy that blog article.Much thanks again. Cool.Really liked this information post.Thanks Again. Can study on...I loved your article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool.xbt news trader scam

Good, thanks for sharing that website post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.Thanks for discussing, this can be a amazing article.Really many thanks! Want more.A major thanks for your blog article.Really many thanks! Fantastic.Great, thanks for sharing this blog.Really thanks! Really Cool.I can't thank you enough for the article.Thanks Again. Fantastic.famoid

Hey thanks for the post. Thanks Again. Want more. I think this is a real great blog post. Really looking forward to read more. Really Cool. voyance pas cher

Really enjoyed this article post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on... appeal lawyers

Great thanks for sharing this blog post. Much thanks again. Awesome. น้ำมันเกียร์

Significant thankies for the blog.Much thanks again.Im thankful for the blog.Much thanks again. Great.Very great report post.Really many thanks! Can study on...Im grateful for the post.Really looking towards read more. Great.I appreciate you sharing this blog.Really looking towards read more. Want more.Thank you ever so for you personally blog article.Really many thanks! Hold writing.link vao fb88

Very neat article post.Really looking forward to read more. Will read on... London tv repair

Hi good post, I truly liked examining it!Thanks for the great informative post. Keep up the truly amazing function :)Thank you for your post.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.Really recognize you discussing that website post.Really thank you! Really Cool.Thank you extremely for you blog article.Thanks Again. Really Great.https://orandocomfe.com

Wow awesome article. Much thanks again. Awesome. bestiphone tempered glass

As life expectancy is increasing, more people are surviving at higher age, degenerative & painful musculo-skeletal disorders are becoming more common. More and more people are suffering from chronic pain. Interventional pain management is a highly specialized medical subject which is very effective in different types of musculo-skeletal & nerve pain. Thus, we need to understand chronic pain more and utilize interventional pain management to alleviate chronic pain for long term.
chronic pain

Looking forward to studying more. Great post.Much thanks again. Cool.Great blog.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.Really enjoyed this short article post.Much thanks again. Great.I am so grateful for the article.Much thanks again. Fantastic.Fantastic blog.Really many thanks! Cool.Fantastic post.Much thanks again. Cool.Coolsculpting Denver, CO

Floohoo is a travel facilitator comprising professionals with over two decades of experience in the travel industry – handling both, frontend and backend operations. We understand your true passion for travel and interesting discoveries, and acts as conduit to flights of fantasy and experiences.Floohoo takes great pleasure in showcasing our specially crafted tour and travel packages.Choose from a wide range of tour packages based on your interests and needs. Kerala House Boat Packages

Liked just of one's website post.Really getting excited about study more. Fantastic.A circular of applause for the post.Much thanks again. Can study on...Thank you very for you blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.Fantastic article. Cool.Looking forward to reading more. Good article.Really thank you!acompanhantes sp

Important thankies for the post.Really getting excited about read more. Awesome.Thanks again for the blog.Really getting excited about study more. Actually Great.Thanks-a-mundo for the website post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.Really appreciate you discussing that blog post.Really looking forward to read more. reat.I price the blog article.Really thank you! Much obliged.Great article post. Hold writing.Loose Diamonds Direct Dallas

Recognize you sharing, great article post. Great.Muchos Gracias for your blog.Really many thanks! Can read on...Great post.Much thanks again. Actually Great.I price the website article.Really getting excited about study more. Really Great.Really enjoy you discussing that article.Really looking towards study more. Actually Great.Wow, good website article.Really many thanks! Awesome.Thanks so much for the article post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.wow, brilliant website post.Really many thanks! Fantastic.

A big thank you for your blog post. Much thanks again. Will read on... seeking man woman

Key thanks for the website article.Really many thanks! Significantly obliged.Enjoyed just of one's blog article. Much obliged.I actually enjoy the blog.Really getting excited about study more. Hold writing.Thanks for sharing, this can be a excellent article.Really getting excited about read more. Actually Great.Awesome article.Really getting excited about read more. Hold writing.Im obliged for the website post.Really thanks! Awesome.Great article. Cool.fhow does your garden mow

Very good article.Really looking forward to study more. Awesome.Great report post.Thanks Again. Really Great.Hey, thanks for the blog post. Will read on...I can't many thanks enough for the post.Really thanks! May read on...Very informative article.Really looking towards read more. Actually Cool.
This is one brilliant blog.Really thanks! Cool.Say, you got a nice blog post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.Awesome report post. Significantly obliged.Awesome report post.Much thanks again. Significantly obliged.Ahmad

Loved every bit of your article post.Really looking towards read more. Much obliged.Thanks again for the post.Thanks Again. Awesome.Really enjoyed this blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.Thanks a lot for the blog article.Really getting excited about read more. Actually Cool.Thanks a lot for this article post.Really many thanks! Awesome.A huge many thanks for your blog.Really thank you! Hold writing.A huge many thanks for the blog.Really looking towards study more. Great.I think this can be a true great website article.Much thanks again. Significantly obliged.. Decorative Wagons For The Yard

Promax7 is the innovation in the latest technology in Cryptocurrency Market which stands in no compete with any miner till date offering 3710 MH/s making it the first and powerful cost efficient miner. This device has been built up with features that increase the basic necessity and increase the output and further leading to shortening of the investment cycle. Bitcoin Miner

Great, thanks for sharing this article post.Thanks Again. Great.Very cool blog article. Keep writing.I think this is a real great website article.Really looking towards study more. Want more.I love and appreciate your website article. Fantastic.Very good post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.Major thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Actually Cool.how to manufacture a product in China

Amazing article.Thanks Again. Actually Cool.Awesome blog.Thanks Again. Significantly obliged.A big thanks for the article.Really thanks! Awesome.Great blog.Much thanks again. Fantastic.Thanks therefore much for the article.Really getting excited about read more. Much obliged.Thank you for the report post. Significantly obliged.I price the blog.Really thank you! Can study on...china sourcing

Actually enjoyed this informative article post.Much thanks again. Cool.
Bridal makeup and hair

Hey, thanks for the blog post. Want more. http://www.magpress.com/blog/how-to-boost-website-speed

We're hence grateful to your blog. Genuinely Great. Cheers for revealing, this specific is a good post. Cool.
Wisdom Jobs Gulf

This content is incredible. I was just thinking about this and I happened to stumble onto your post. I wish there was more of this kind of quality online these days. Wordpress webdesign

Awesome dispatch! I am indeed getting apt to over this info, is truly neighborly my buddy. Likewise fantastic blog here among many of the costly info you acquire. Reserve up the beneficial process you are doing here. Test Bank for Andersons Business Law and the Legal Environment 23rd Edition by Twomey

I truly recognize basically analyzing the lion's offer of your weblogs. Just anticipated that would provoke you that you have individuals like me who regard your work. Irrefutably a superb post. Finish off to you! The data that you have given is phenomenally significant. orthodontst tyler tx

First You got a great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics. ΑΠΟΦΡΑΞΕΙΣ ΑΘΗΝΑ

Our business is to support the best emerging ICOs at certain and sustainable costs by giving them the tools and visibility necessary to generate real and last value for investors and underwriters. ico promotion service

αποφραξεις τιμες Great tips and very easy to understand. This will definitely be very useful for me when I get a chance to start my blog. dissertation for college

I was very pleased to find this site.I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post. blogger outreach by eXthus

croche todo dia I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. voyance discount Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. site de croche

garage door repair Brooklyn NY I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. kitchen remodeling contractors Los Angeles Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. garage door repair Tacoma WA

I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job! weight loss supplements


This is extremely fascinating substance! I have altogether delighted in perusing your focuses and have reached the conclusion that you are appropriate about a significant number of them. You are extraordinary. black diamond engagement rings



wheelsshop First You got a great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics. http://20kgpa29dagar.smelink.se

There is so much in this article that I would never have thought of on my own. Your content gives readers things to think about in an interesting way. Preventivo impianto fotovoltaico

Gangaur Realtech is a professionally regulated affiliation invest noteworthy energy in arrive organizations where fused organizations are given by specialists to its clients searching for extended a motivating force by owning, having or placing assets into arrive. denied long term disability lawyer

It is perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I’ve read this post and if I could I desire to suggest you few interesting things or tips. Perhaps you could write next articles referring to this article. I want to read more things about it! voyance gratuite immediate par telephone



canon 104 toner wow, great, I was wondering how to cure acne naturally. and found your site by google, learned a lot, now i’m a bit clear. I’ve bookmark your site and also add rss. keep us updated. download showbox

Took me time to understand all of the comments, but I seriously enjoyed the write-up. It proved being really helpful to me and Im positive to all of the commenters right here! Its constantly nice when you can not only be informed, but also entertained! I am certain you had enjoyable writing this write-up. Stephen Pierce Internet Marketing

I researed valuable information on this point as I am working on a class project. Thank you posting useful information and its now becoming easier to accomplish this task. og youtube 2018

Remote-Controlled Toys I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I found in you post. Thanks for sharing. breast augmentation

amofazercroche.com I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work. voyance gratuite par telephone Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful. graficos de croche barbante jogo de banheiro