A People's History of Baseball

A special Labor Day weekend book excerpt
Share |
A People's History of Baseball

Courtesy of University of Illinois Press

Mitchell Nathanson's A People's History of Baseball is a rewarding detour from the usual sepia dad-whispering of diamond history. Nathanson, a legal scholar, looks at what he calls "counter-stories" from baseball's past and present to see how the simple myths of the game often mask power struggles and politics. After digging the excerpt, we have a bonus Q&A with Nathanson for your Labor Day embiggenment. Here's an excerpt from Chapter Five: "Wait Till Next Year" and the Denial of History.

Despite reality, which necessarily must conclude that underdogs have a less than equal chance of emerging victorious (if they did not, they would be favorites), many Americans somehow believe otherwise. This delusion allows us to preach high-mindedly but to remain disengaged from the struggle—for in our minds the downtrodden will emerge victorious on their own, without the need of aid. This mindset is consistent with American actions, as opposed to the verbal gymnastics used to nevertheless equate “American” values with support for the truly disadvantaged. In sports, the American penchant of rooting for the underdog really has more to do with rooting for the favorite in the mind’s eye—reality be damned. In life, traditional American attitudes toward disadvantaged groups (ones defined by an absence of the type of “looming success” that pervades the American definition of “underdog”) show little sympathy or empathy for actual victims of social injustice—Native and African Americans, immigrants, and women, to name but a few such groups. All of the perceived “American” values somehow fall by the wayside in the face of true disadvantage. It is therefore not surprising that the American definition of “underdog” does not extend far beyond the sports arena. In an athletic contest, we can sit passively in the stands holding firm to our stated beliefs without concern that we will be called upon to act on them. Once the game ends, however, and our beliefs have consequences, we are more likely to shy away from them.

In the end, it is not the underdog after all that Americans cherish. It is instead the optimism to believe that the underdog will win despite reasonable, concrete evidence to the contrary. Returning to the Australians for a moment, it becomes clear that besides a shared attraction to the term, Americans and Australians actually have very little in common when it comes to the national ethos supporting underdogs. Perhaps Americans are unique when it comes to our support for underdogs, but not in the way we normally assume. What may be unique about us (or at least unusual) is not our affection for the term but our delusion fueled by unwarranted optimism that underdogs will emerge victorious more often than not, even though by definition, they will not. It is this unwarranted optimism that, as it turns out, opens the door for what we would otherwise conclude are some very “un-American” behaviors by those claiming precisely the opposite allegiance.

For more than a century, unwarranted, irrational optimism has been seen by some of its critics and most ardent supporters alike as a diversionary device used to great effect to preserve the status quo and fend off change: the heroic stories of underdogs (from Horatio Alger’s tales onward) being fodder used to present the facade of overcoming even the most dire of situations, which in the process diverts attention from the world as it actually exists. With each underdog that emerges victorious, the focus remains on the extraordinary individual who accomplished the feat rather than on the situation that created the imbalance that necessitated the superhuman acts to surmount it. The psychologist and philosopher William James, although considered a “hero” of what would come to be known as the “positive thinking movement,” recognized as much a century ago when he noted that unfettered optimism and happiness presented potential dangers, given that they require “blindness and insensibility to opposing facts.” Although James did not conclude that such happiness was itself a sickness (indeed he believed it to be the socially desired state), the historian Donald Meyer noted that it led to a vulnerability to sickness if the achievement of a state of perpetual bliss became one’s overarching priority. In this way, the shutting out of opposing information and facts was, in James’s view, “wait ’til next year” and the denial of history under certain conditions “quasi-pathological”—although in his view this was not necessarily a bad thing. Several decades later Roth, a critic of the movement, would sound a similar, although more desolate, theme in The Great American Novel when his protagonist considered the magical pull of the word “America” and all it connotes: “America? … [W]hat’s America to you? Or to me? Or to those tens of thousands up in the stands? It’s just a word they use to keep your nose to the grindstone and your toes to the line. America is the opiate of the people …”

Sports, particularly baseball as well as the popular depiction of baseball as America, have helped to grease the wheels of the status quo through tales of triumphant underdogs to the point where that seventy-five-yearold Cubs fan could believe from the stands at Wrigley that this, irrespective of the last hundred, was the year his Cubbies were finally going to put it all together. This mindset, “quasi-pathological” at a minimum, is at its essence quintessentially American. Although the unquestioning devotion, the “blindness and insensibility to opposing facts,” ironically increases the likelihood of this fan’s perpetual misery (after all, there is little incentive for real change to occur if hope and optimism remain regardless of results), he is supportive nevertheless, for to abandon hope is contrary to the national character.

As it turns out, it is by design that this fan, along with countless others, feels this way and continues to look for roses—at the ballpark and, more importantly and with greater consequences, elsewhere—where there are only thorns. For as Americans we are the product of decades’ worth of rhetoric aimed directly at us with the goal of encouraging us to resign ourselves to the status quo and ignore our feelings of unease over our own place within the existing social structure; to give in and accept our fate rather than challenge a social and economic hierarchy where the overwhelming majority of wealth, power, and benefits reside with an ever-shrinking few. This rhetoric is evidenced within the baseball creed and has its roots in the societal upheaval caused by the rapid industrialization of America during the last half of the nineteenth century. The positive thinking movement would find a natural ally in baseball very early on as it attempted to calm the fears of those who had the means, numbers, and ability to overthrow the status quo if something was not done quickly.

Copyright 2012 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois. Used with permission of the University of Illinois Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be reprinted, photocopied, posted online or distributed in any way without the written permission of the copyright holder.

Share |


It is quite beneficial, although think about the facts when it reaches this target. real estate drone

Just admiring your work and wondering how you managed this blog so well. It’s so remarkable that I can't afford to not go through this valuable information whenever I surf the internet! M88

Nice post! This is a very nice blog that I will definitively come back to more times this year! Thanks for informative post. Judi Online

Başarılı veya karlılığa ihtiyacı olan firmalariçin dönüşüm yönetimi, karlı büyüme, Yönetim danışmanlığı Firmaları

I found your this post while searching for information about blog-related research ... It's a good post .. keep posting and updating information. http://www.cheap-flower-delivery.org.uk/

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. flooring Edinburgh

This is exactly each an awesome content and articles document really quite quite beloved reading. This isn't on daily basis i feature capability to work out a huge concern. bayi.crovu.co

This is exactly each an awesome content and articles document really quite quite beloved reading. This isn't on daily basis i feature capability to work out a huge concern. bayi.crovu.co

This is exactly each an awesome content and articles document really quite quite beloved reading. This isn't on daily basis i feature capability to work out a huge concern. bayi.crovu.co

This is very interesting content! I have thoroughly enjoyed reading your points and have come to the conclusion that you are right about many of them. You are great. what to eat during pregnancy

You have a good point here!I totally agree with what you have said!!Thanks for sharing your views...hope more people will read this article!!! pokerpelangi188.xyz

It was a very good post indeed. I thoroughly enjoyed reading it in my lunch time. Will surely come and visit this blog more often. Thanks for sharing. moral stories for kids

Listed here you'll learn it is important, them offers the link in an helpful webpage: 더킹카지노

Yes i am totally agreed with this article and i just want say that this article is very nice and very informative article.I will make sure to be reading your blog more. You made a good point but I can't help but wonder, what about the other side? !!!!!!Thanks Home inspector(s)

Awesome article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged. happy new year quotes

Thank you for your blog post.Much thanks again. Really Cool. lifelike sex dolls

Great post.Thanks Again. Much obliged. Sample CPA firm engagement letter">tax engagement letter

israelnightclub.com Some people are very fond of reading books will be able to distinguish the best book as a guide and a book that is not good. It all depends with your reading experience.

Thanks so much for the blog. Thanks Again. Much obliged. lung supplement

I value the blog post.Thanks Again. Awesome. รถยนต์

Enjoyed every bit of your article.Thanks Again. Really Great. florida

Im thankful for the article.Really thank you! Will read on... mp3converter

I am so grateful for your article.Much thanks again. Fantastic. check here

Wow, great blog.Thanks Again. Great. Emergency dentists

Really enjoyed this article post.Really thank you! Will read on... seeking man woman

Mmm.. amazing to be here in your article or post, whatever, I figure I ought to also secure for my own specific site like I see some phenomenal and stimulated working in your site. Security guard companies New York

Good to become visiting your weblog again, it has been months for me. Nicely this article that i've been waited for so long. I will need this post to total my assignment in the college, and it has exact same topic together with your write-up. Thanks, good share. Rekeying Locks

When your website or blog goes live for the first time, it is exciting. That is until you realize no one but you and your. Bandar Togel Terpercaya

A website about small businesses. SMB

Wonderful data, useful and exemplary style, as reveal excellent stuff with great some ideas and ideas, plenty of great data and enthusiasm, equally that I need, thanks to supply such a beneficial information here. I simply surely got to this amazing website shortly ago. I was really captured with the bit of methods you 've got here. Big thumbs up for making such amazing website site!Website

I was exactly searching for. Thanks for such post and please hold it up. Great work. Hi! That post couldn't be prepared much better! Reading this post reminds me of my past room spouse! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this page to him. Pretty particular he can have a good read. Thanks for sharing!Free Book PDF

Appreciate you discussing, great blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.Great, thanks for discussing this informative article post.Really many thanks! Actually Cool.Im pleased for the website post. Need more.Looking forward to reading more. Good blog.Really looking towards study more.child pornography

Remarkable article, it is particularly useful! I quietly began in this, and I'm becoming more acquainted with it better! Delights, keep doing more and extra impressive! window blinds

Exceptionally helpful post. This is my first time i visit here. I discovered such a variety of intriguing stuff in your web journal particularly its examination. Truly its incredible article. Keep it up. Ebook PDF Free

The site is delicately adjusted and spared as much as date. So it ought to be, a commitment of thankfulness is all together to offer this to us. Lagos properties for rent

Yes i am completely concurred with this article and i simply need say this article is extremely decent and exceptionally useful article.I will make a point to be perusing your blog more. You made a decent point yet I can't resist the urge to ponder, shouldn't something be said about the other side? !!!!!!THANKS!!!!!! UFABET

I liked your blog.Really many thanks!Thanks-a-mundo for the article. Awesome.This is one great blog.Really looking towards study more. Actually Great.Thanks again for the content post.Thanks Again. Awesome.Hair regrowth shampoo

Thank you ever so for you post.Really looking forward to read more. betwin360

Looking forward to reading more. Great post.Really thank you! Want more. cbd oil merchant account

Thanks-a-mundo for the blog.Really thank you! Great. Office Space Johannesburg

Hey, thanks for the post.Thanks Again. Want more. South African Motivational Speakers

Fantastic blog.Really thank you! Cool.Fantastic post.Much thanks again. Cool.I truly enjoy that blog.Thanks Again. Hold writing.Wow, good article. Fantastic.This is one great website article.Much thanks again.hampton bay

Significant thanks for the blog article.Really thank you! May study on...A circular of applause for your blog.Really many thanks! Fantastic.I think this can be a true good blog. Really Great.I actually benefit from the blog.Really many thanks! Really Cool.hampton bay

This is the type of information I’ve long been trying to find. Thank you for writing this information. hampton bay

Great, thanks for sharing this article post.Really thank you! Keep writing. situs poker online

Very good written article. It will be supportive to anyone who utilizes it, including me. Keep doing what you are doing – can’r wait to read more posts.
κατσαριδες φαρμακο κυπρος

This is a grand article, Given such an exceptional measure of data in it, These sort of articles keeps the customers vitality for the site, and keep sharing more ... positive conditions. แทงบอลฟรี

You may remark on the request design of the blog. You should visit it's brain boggling. Your blog review would swell up your guests. I was to an awesome degree satisfied to discover this site.I anticipated that would thank you for this impossible read!! hire minibus paris

Enjoyed every bit of your blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic. 200-125 dumps

I unquestionably esteeming each and every piece of it and I have you bookmarked to look at new stuff you post. คาสิโนออนไลน์เครดิตฟรี